AI summary by TwinMind
Why is colonialism (still) romanticized? | Farish Ahmad-Noor
TED
12m 19s
Speaker Background and Research Focus
- Historian with philosophy background
- Main research: Southeast Asian history, 19th century colonial Southeast Asia
- Recent work: tracing history of ideas shaping Asian/Southeast Asian self-perception and understanding
Core Historical Puzzle
- Cannot explain as historian: why certain ideas/viewpoints persist and never disappear
- Specific interest: why some postcolonial Asians maintain romanticized view of colonial past
- View through "rose tinted lenses" as benevolent/pleasant time
- Despite historians knowing realities of violence, oppression, dark side of colonial experience
Time Machine Thought Experiment
- Hypothetical: sending self back to 1860s (100 years before speaker's birth)
- In 19th century colonial Southeast Asia context, would not be professor
- Despite historical knowledge, some quarters still romanticize that murky past
Limits of Historical Method
- Can trace ideas, find origins of cliches/stereotypes
- Can identify who created them, where, when, in which book
- Cannot access internal subjective mental universe to change minds
- This limitation drives interest in psychology and cognitive behavioral therapy
Psychology and Persistence of Ideas
- Scholars in psychology/CBT examine persistence of ideas
- Why prejudices, biases, phobias persist (misogyny, racism, islamophobia)
- Reason: fall back on finite pool of basic unchallenged ideas when viewing world
Southeast Asian Self-Representation Examples
- Tourist campaigns: obligatory coconut tree, orangutan (unpaid)
- Media representation patterns:
- Sitcoms/dramas: countryside people portrayed as ugly, funny, silly, without knowledge
- Countryside seen as having nothing to offer
- Nature treatment:
- Despite talk of Asian philosophy, Asian values, organic relationship to nature
- Actually regard nature as something to be defeated and exploited
Colonial Legacy in Contemporary Ideas
- Postcolonial Southeast Asia bears residual traces of colonial-era ideas/tropes/cliches/stereotypes
- Countryside as place to exploit, country folk as without knowledge
- These stereotypes emerged when Southeast Asia governed by colonial capitalism logic
- Ideas taken with us, now part of us, but lack critical self-interrogation
- Don't ask: how did I get this worldview of nature, countryside, Asia as exotic?
Self-Exoticization Phenomenon
- Southeast Asians love to self-exoticize
- Turned Southeast Asian identity into cosplay
- Can buy "do-it-yourself exotic Southeast Asian costume kit" at supermarket/mall
- Parade identity without questioning when/how particular self-image emerged
Interdisciplinary Collaboration Need
- Historian limitations: archival work alone insufficient
- No point tracing idea genesis for journal read by three historians
- Must engage with:
- Psychology, behavioral therapy
- Sociologists, anthropologists, political economists
- Arts and media people
- Debates need to occur outside university confines
Future Challenges for Southeast Asia
- Region will face enormous unprecedented changes:
- Globalization
- World politics, geopolitical contestations
- Technology impact, fourth industrial revolution
- To adapt, need to think outside box
- Cannot fall back on same cliched, tired, stale stereotypes
- Need interdisciplinary engagement
Alternative Histories
- Current state not determined by fixed "iron historical railway track"
- Many other histories, ideas were forgotten, marginalized, erased
- Historians' job: uncover/discover these alternatives
- Must engage with society as whole
Second Time Machine Example
- 19th century colonial subject wondering if empire will end, if freedom will come
- Invents time machine, arrives in postcolonial Southeast Asia today
- Observes: imperial flags/gunboats/armies gone, new nation states, independence achieved
- But watches tourist ads: same banana tree, coconut tree, orangutan
- Sees TV reproducing exotic Southeast Asia images by Southeast Asians themselves
- Conclusion: despite colonialism ending, still living in long shadow of 19th century
Personal Mission Statement
- History must go beyond history
- Need to reignite debate about who/what we are
- Viewpoints never entirely individual - we are social/historical beings
- Carry history in language, fiction, movies, self-images
- While determined by history, need not be trapped by it
- Need not be victims of history
