AI summary by TwinMind

Why is everyone so unhappy with JavaScript?

Theo - t3․gg

47m 13s

Survey Overview & Demographics

  • 2024 marked a "slow year" for JavaScript - fewer new APIs and frameworks compared to 2023
  • Top 3 frontend frameworks (React, Vue, Angular) all launched over a decade ago
  • 15% of respondents from US, median age slightly younger than previous surveys
  • 43% of respondents between 30-39 years old
  • Strong correlation between age and income - people over 30 make less than 25-29 age group initially
  • 75% of respondents have college degrees
  • Degree holders make significantly more money on average despite claims that "you don't need a degree"
  • Gender ratio better than expected due to renewed outreach efforts

Sponsor Segment - Code Rabbit

  • AI-powered code review bot for GitHub pull requests
  • Provides line-by-line reviews, summaries, and commit suggestions
  • Caught PHP naming convention errors (camelCase vs underscores)
  • One-click commit suggestions accepted by engineers
  • $12/month base subscription, free for open source
  • Promo code: Theo1M for one month free

JavaScript Language Features Adoption

  • Nullish coalescing: 85% adoption - "awesome" growth
  • Dynamic imports: 70% usage, higher than expected
  • Private fields: 45% adoption, surprisingly high
  • Logical assignment: 44% usage
  • String.replaceAll: Only 76% adoption despite being essential
    • String.replace only replacing first occurrence called "most unintuitive behavior"
  • Array methods:
    • toSorted(), toReversed(), toSpliced() creating new arrays vs mutating originals
    • Should have been default behavior from start
  • Promise.allSettled: Recommended over Promise.all for most use cases
  • Set operations: Union, intersection features underutilized despite usefulness

Browser APIs Usage

  • WebSockets: Widely adopted as expected
  • PWA: 49% usage, higher than anticipated but "feel dead"
  • Geolocation: 35% usage seems inflated, "terrifying" that it's 2x more popular than WebGL
  • WebRTC: Surprisingly low adoption
  • Temporal: Still waiting to ship

Framework Sentiment Analysis

React

  • 47% positive, 30% neutral, 20% negative sentiment
  • Still considered dominant but sentiment declining due to widespread adoption
  • Average React developer didn't choose React - assigned to projects using it
  • Complexity + involuntary adoption = worse sentiment

Next.js

  • Similar sentiment pattern to React (35% positive, 47% neutral, 35% negative)
  • Becoming "the way businesses use React"
  • Sentiment expected to worsen as more developers forced to use it without choosing
  • More people using Next.js aren't using it by choice

Vue

  • 42% positive, 17% negative - better sentiment than React
  • Some Vue developers feel "burned by Vue 3" (incorrectly according to presenter)

Angular

  • 23% positive, 40% negative - worst sentiment
  • Making improvements again after stagnation period

Svelte/SvelteKit

  • Negative sentiment swing despite Svelte 5 being "great release"
  • API changes when reaching stable release upset developers
  • Some Svelte developers preferred it as non-framework, now upset it's becoming "big framework"

Framework Adoption Patterns

  • Popularity vs Sentiment Inverse Relationship: As tools become more popular, sentiment decreases
  • Pattern: Tools go "up and then left" on usage vs sentiment charts
  • React only framework consistently breaking 50/50 usage line
  • Most frameworks drifting left (negative sentiment) in 2024
  • Only Angular moved right due to recent improvements

Meta-Framework Landscape

Usage Rankings

  • Next.js: 54% usage, maintaining #1 position
  • No framework: Second most common approach for full-stack
  • Astro: 23% usage, climbed from 6th to 2nd place (2022-2024)
  • Remix: Significant decline in rankings
  • SvelteKit: Mixed sentiment despite technical improvements

Growth Analysis

  • Astro doubled from 2022-2023, slower growth 2023-2024
  • Next.js gap still substantial - Astro would need to double again to match
  • 31% of developers haven't used any meta-frameworks
  • More people unaware of meta-frameworks than people using Astro

Testing Tools

  • Jest: Still most popular
  • Storybook: Higher adoption than expected, though presenter considers it problematic
  • Playwright: Growing fast, "really good" tool
  • 21% haven't used any testing tools

Build Tools & Development

Vite Dominance

  • Continues climbing but growth rate slowing
  • "Every project that should be using Vite is at this point"
  • Remaining projects stuck on webpack due to complex plugin dependencies
  • Even Vite showing slight negative sentiment drift

Webpack

  • 18% positive, 47% neutral, 35% negative sentiment
  • Still pays better salaries than newer tools
  • Deeply integrated into Next.js, making migration difficult

Monorepo Tools

  • pnpm: Leading package manager
  • Turbo: Growth slowed massively
  • NX: Doing fine but not dominating
  • Monorepos remain "unsolved problem" - happiness metrics never improved
  • Most people only know Turbo when it's broken or they configured it

Developer Happiness Trends

  • Overall happiness flatlined - no improvement in 5 years across categories
  • Frontend developer sentiment getting more negative despite tools not getting worse
  • 2024 pattern: Nearly everything moved left (negative) on sentiment charts
  • Framework authors putting effort in but not seeing happiness improvements
  • Suggests developers becoming more frustrated/negative generally

Technology Adoption Highlights

TypeScript Dominance

  • Less than 20% of developers use under 50% TypeScript
  • TypeScript decisively won the adoption battle

AI/Development Tools

  • ChatGPT: More users than GitHub Copilot (surprising)
  • Cursor: Only IDE over 10% adoption, "slaughtering" competition
  • Most developers writing 0-10% AI-generated code

Hosting/Deployment

  • Vercel: Getting close to AWS for hosting
  • Heroku: Still 19% usage, "time to move off"
  • Netlify: Beating Cloudflare

Backend Frameworks

  • Express: Still dominating
  • Fastify: Underrated, presenter's go-to for non-Next.js projects
  • Nest: Twice as popular as Fastify (disappointing to presenter)

Content Creator Rankings

  • Presenter ranked close to Fireship in developer resources
  • Midudev: 4th place overall, representing vibrant Spanish-language ecosystem
  • Spanish-only creator having double the next English creator's reach is "huge"

Survey Conclusions & Concerns

  • Innovation Dilemma: Not innovating doesn't help sentiment, but innovating gets penalized
  • Developer Negativity: General trend toward more negative sentiment regardless of actual tool improvements
  • Adoption vs Choice: Most developers using popular tools didn't choose them
  • Education Gap: Need better materials to help involuntary adopters become enthusiastic
  • Future Concerns: Worried about web development world becoming scared of innovation

Key Takeaways

  • JavaScript ecosystem stability (top frameworks over decade old) vs constant change perception
  • Sentiment declining across nearly all tools in 2024
  • Success paradox: Popular tools get worse sentiment due to involuntary adoption
  • Framework authors facing thankless task - effort doesn't translate to improved developer happiness

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome