AI summary by TwinMind

Why is the Equal Rights Amendment still not ratified? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

49m 18s

Introduction and Context

  • Podcast: Stuff You Should Know (iHeartRadio production)
  • Hosts: Josh Clark, Chuck Bryan, Jerry (producer)
  • Listener correction: Suffragette vs. suffragist terminology
    • Suffragette was disparaging term used by British reporters early 1900s to mock women's voting rights activists
    • Suffragist is correct term
  • Topic suggestion from Jeraine Bailey (couple years ago) and Mary Malinaskis (recent correction)

Equal Rights Amendment Overview

  • Constitutional amendment providing equal protection under law for women
  • Would prohibit discrimination based on sex in lawmaking
  • AP 2020 poll findings:
    • 72% thought equal protection already existed in Constitution
    • 75% supported enshrining protection when told it wasn't there
  • Current bipartisan support challenge: public vs. Congressional agreement disconnect

Early History (1920s-1970s)

  • First versions written early 1920s by suffragist Alice Paul and Crystal Eastman
  • Also helped pass 19th Amendment (women's right to vote, 1920)
  • Originally called "Lucretia Mott Amendment" after 19th century Quaker suffragist/abolitionist
  • 1943 rewording by Alice Paul to sound more constitutional
  • New version: "Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex"
  • Proposed every Congressional session 1922-1970, consistently failed
  • Emmanuel Seller (Democrat, New York) blocked House Judiciary Committee votes
  • Seller lost 1972 primary to Elizabeth Holtzman largely due to ERA opposition

Liberal vs. Conservative Position Flip

  • Original opposition: New Deal liberals (Eleanor Roosevelt)
    • Feared undermining workplace protections
    • Roosevelt chaired Kennedy's Commission on Status of Women
    • Commission concluded ERA wasn't necessary (released posthumously)
    • Roosevelt eventually stopped opposing but never fully endorsed
  • Original support: Eisenhower conservatives
  • Public debates between Alice Paul and Eleanor Roosevelt

Second Wave Feminism and Betty Friedan

  • Betty Friedan's "The Feminine Mystique" (1964) sold 1 million copies
  • Originated from college reunion survey showing female classmates' dissatisfaction with homemaker roles
  • Challenged idea that wife/mother identity was women's highest aspiration
  • Sparked second wave of feminism
  • Friedan portrayed by Tracy Ullman in "Mrs. America" miniseries

Congressional Passage (1972)

  • More women entering Congress: Bella Abzug, Shirley Chisholm
  • Bipartisan passage: 93.4% House, 91.3% Senate
  • Required 38 states (two-thirds) for ratification
  • Seven-year deadline attached to legislation (not amendment itself)
  • No previous amendment had expiration date

Initial Ratification Success

  • 30 of 38 needed states ratified within one year
  • Proponents optimistic about quick ratification

Phyllis Schlafly and Opposition Movement

  • Founded "Stop ERA" (Stop Taking Our Privileges)
  • Background: Masters in political science, law degree, ran for Congress at 27
  • Presented herself as "housewife from St. Louis, mother of six"
  • Skilled debater who could rattle opponents while maintaining composure
  • Portrayed by Cate Blanchett in "Mrs. America"

Schlafly's Arguments and Tactics

  • Warned ERA would lead to:
    • Women being drafted into military
    • Elimination of separate bathrooms/locker rooms
    • Loss of alimony and child support rights
    • Same-sex marriage
  • Linked ERA to abortion rights after Roe v. Wade (1973)
  • Consolidated conservative Christian voters
  • Created foundation for modern Republican party from Reagan onward
  • Used inflammatory rhetoric: called gay people "perverts," said sexual harassment wasn't problem for "virtuous women"

Famous Debates

  • 1976 Good Morning America debate with Betty Friedan
  • Schlafly's calm demeanor vs. Friedan's visible frustration
  • Schlafly's tactic of highlighting "angry feminists"

Ratification Stalemate

  • By 1977: 35 states ratified (needed 38)
  • Five states rescinded ratification: Nebraska, Tennessee, Idaho, Kentucky, South Dakota
  • Precedent: Ohio and New Jersey rescinded 14th Amendment support but Congress ignored it
  • Three-year extension granted, deadline moved to 1982
  • ERA supporters gave up by 1982 when no additional states ratified

Modern Revival (2017-2020)

  • 2017: Nevada became 36th state (first new ratification in 40 years)
    • State Senator Pat Spearman: "This bill is about equality, period"
  • 2018: Illinois became 37th state
  • January 2020: Virginia became 38th state
  • Lawsuits filed against National Archives and Records Administration
  • Ruth Bader Ginsburg supported starting over rather than using expired process

Current Legal Protections

  • Civil Rights Act of 1964: prohibited sex discrimination in employment
  • Equal Pay Act of 1963: equal pay for equal work
  • Violence Against Women Act of 1994: federal resources for domestic/sexual violence
    • Expired 2019, still awaiting Congressional reauthorization
  • Title IX (1972): gender equality in education, especially college athletics

Constitutional vs. Legislative Protection

  • Sex currently protected class under 14th Amendment interpretation
  • Ruth Bader Ginsburg pioneered using 14th Amendment for sex discrimination cases
  • Different levels of judicial scrutiny:
    • Strict scrutiny: Constitutional protections (hardest to overcome)
    • Intermediate scrutiny: Legislative protections (easier to challenge)
  • Constitutional protection would make discrimination nearly impossible to justify

Modern Arguments For ERA

  • Laws can be reversed, precedents overturned
  • Antonin Scalia quote: Constitution "most decidedly does not" protect against sex discrimination
  • Would address issues like:
    • Pink tax (women charged more for similar products)
    • Menstrual equity (tax-free feminine hygiene products)
  • Current abortion connection: only women get abortions, so abortion restrictions could be seen as sex discrimination

International Context

  • US one of only 28 countries without gender equality guarantee
  • 100% of countries writing constitutions since 1950 included gender equality
  • Examples: Nepal struck down marital rape exemption, Tanzania eliminated discriminatory marriage age laws

Call to Action

  • Advice: Pick one issue and dedicate yourself to it rather than bouncing between causes
  • Suggestion: Make ERA passage your specialty if this issue resonates

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome