AI summary by TwinMind
Why is the Equal Rights Amendment still not ratified? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
49m 18s
Introduction and Context
- Podcast: Stuff You Should Know (iHeartRadio production)
- Hosts: Josh Clark, Chuck Bryan, Jerry (producer)
- Listener correction: Suffragette vs. suffragist terminology
- Suffragette was disparaging term used by British reporters early 1900s to mock women's voting rights activists
- Suffragist is correct term
- Topic suggestion from Jeraine Bailey (couple years ago) and Mary Malinaskis (recent correction)
Equal Rights Amendment Overview
- Constitutional amendment providing equal protection under law for women
- Would prohibit discrimination based on sex in lawmaking
- AP 2020 poll findings:
- 72% thought equal protection already existed in Constitution
- 75% supported enshrining protection when told it wasn't there
- Current bipartisan support challenge: public vs. Congressional agreement disconnect
Early History (1920s-1970s)
- First versions written early 1920s by suffragist Alice Paul and Crystal Eastman
- Also helped pass 19th Amendment (women's right to vote, 1920)
- Originally called "Lucretia Mott Amendment" after 19th century Quaker suffragist/abolitionist
- 1943 rewording by Alice Paul to sound more constitutional
- New version: "Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex"
- Proposed every Congressional session 1922-1970, consistently failed
- Emmanuel Seller (Democrat, New York) blocked House Judiciary Committee votes
- Seller lost 1972 primary to Elizabeth Holtzman largely due to ERA opposition
Liberal vs. Conservative Position Flip
- Original opposition: New Deal liberals (Eleanor Roosevelt)
- Feared undermining workplace protections
- Roosevelt chaired Kennedy's Commission on Status of Women
- Commission concluded ERA wasn't necessary (released posthumously)
- Roosevelt eventually stopped opposing but never fully endorsed
- Original support: Eisenhower conservatives
- Public debates between Alice Paul and Eleanor Roosevelt
Second Wave Feminism and Betty Friedan
- Betty Friedan's "The Feminine Mystique" (1964) sold 1 million copies
- Originated from college reunion survey showing female classmates' dissatisfaction with homemaker roles
- Challenged idea that wife/mother identity was women's highest aspiration
- Sparked second wave of feminism
- Friedan portrayed by Tracy Ullman in "Mrs. America" miniseries
Congressional Passage (1972)
- More women entering Congress: Bella Abzug, Shirley Chisholm
- Bipartisan passage: 93.4% House, 91.3% Senate
- Required 38 states (two-thirds) for ratification
- Seven-year deadline attached to legislation (not amendment itself)
- No previous amendment had expiration date
Initial Ratification Success
- 30 of 38 needed states ratified within one year
- Proponents optimistic about quick ratification
Phyllis Schlafly and Opposition Movement
- Founded "Stop ERA" (Stop Taking Our Privileges)
- Background: Masters in political science, law degree, ran for Congress at 27
- Presented herself as "housewife from St. Louis, mother of six"
- Skilled debater who could rattle opponents while maintaining composure
- Portrayed by Cate Blanchett in "Mrs. America"
Schlafly's Arguments and Tactics
- Warned ERA would lead to:
- Women being drafted into military
- Elimination of separate bathrooms/locker rooms
- Loss of alimony and child support rights
- Same-sex marriage
- Linked ERA to abortion rights after Roe v. Wade (1973)
- Consolidated conservative Christian voters
- Created foundation for modern Republican party from Reagan onward
- Used inflammatory rhetoric: called gay people "perverts," said sexual harassment wasn't problem for "virtuous women"
Famous Debates
- 1976 Good Morning America debate with Betty Friedan
- Schlafly's calm demeanor vs. Friedan's visible frustration
- Schlafly's tactic of highlighting "angry feminists"
Ratification Stalemate
- By 1977: 35 states ratified (needed 38)
- Five states rescinded ratification: Nebraska, Tennessee, Idaho, Kentucky, South Dakota
- Precedent: Ohio and New Jersey rescinded 14th Amendment support but Congress ignored it
- Three-year extension granted, deadline moved to 1982
- ERA supporters gave up by 1982 when no additional states ratified
Modern Revival (2017-2020)
- 2017: Nevada became 36th state (first new ratification in 40 years)
- State Senator Pat Spearman: "This bill is about equality, period"
- 2018: Illinois became 37th state
- January 2020: Virginia became 38th state
- Lawsuits filed against National Archives and Records Administration
- Ruth Bader Ginsburg supported starting over rather than using expired process
Current Legal Protections
- Civil Rights Act of 1964: prohibited sex discrimination in employment
- Equal Pay Act of 1963: equal pay for equal work
- Violence Against Women Act of 1994: federal resources for domestic/sexual violence
- Expired 2019, still awaiting Congressional reauthorization
- Title IX (1972): gender equality in education, especially college athletics
Constitutional vs. Legislative Protection
- Sex currently protected class under 14th Amendment interpretation
- Ruth Bader Ginsburg pioneered using 14th Amendment for sex discrimination cases
- Different levels of judicial scrutiny:
- Strict scrutiny: Constitutional protections (hardest to overcome)
- Intermediate scrutiny: Legislative protections (easier to challenge)
- Constitutional protection would make discrimination nearly impossible to justify
Modern Arguments For ERA
- Laws can be reversed, precedents overturned
- Antonin Scalia quote: Constitution "most decidedly does not" protect against sex discrimination
- Would address issues like:
- Pink tax (women charged more for similar products)
- Menstrual equity (tax-free feminine hygiene products)
- Current abortion connection: only women get abortions, so abortion restrictions could be seen as sex discrimination
International Context
- US one of only 28 countries without gender equality guarantee
- 100% of countries writing constitutions since 1950 included gender equality
- Examples: Nepal struck down marital rape exemption, Tanzania eliminated discriminatory marriage age laws
Call to Action
- Advice: Pick one issue and dedicate yourself to it rather than bouncing between causes
- Suggestion: Make ERA passage your specialty if this issue resonates
