AI summary by TwinMind
Why is TSMC Doing Better in Japan?
Asianometry
19m 55s
TSMC Fab Development Timeline Comparison
- TSMC Japan (JASM) announced November 2021, launched February 2024 ceremony
- 20 months from announcement to fab start
- Morris Chang gave speech, Japanese government announced support for second phase
- Rumors of third phase in development
- TSMC Arizona announced May 2020, still under construction
- Second phase size depends on CHIPS Act subsidies
- Chips from second phase not expected until 2028
- Added last steel beam February 2024
Semiconductor Fab Complexity
- Fabrication facility = ultimate expression of haste and unforgiving precision
- Process flow: hundreds of steps over many months
- Major functions: oxidation, deposition, photolithography, ion implant, metalization, cleaning
- Up to 500 tools in clean room environment
- Global average: 1.9 years construction to production start
- Single fab costs tens of billions in capital investment
- TSMC pledged $40 billion for two Arizona phases
- Tools rapidly depreciate, only viable at nearly 100% utilization
Geographic and Logistical Factors
- Taiwan-Japan distance: 1-2 hour flight vs 12-14 hour flight to US
- Kumamoto on Kyushu island, geographically close to Taiwan
- Distance delays urgent responses, stretches suppliers beyond previous limits
- Precedent exists: Japanese car companies (Toyota, Honda) successfully transplanted culture to US
- Intel successfully built advanced fabs in Ireland and Israel
Technology Node Differences
- Japan JASM processes:
- Phase 1: 28nm, 22nm technology, 16nm/12nm FinFET node
- Phase 2: N6 (7nm class process)
- Rumored Phase 3: N4 or better
- Arizona processes:
- Started with N5 (5nm node), upgraded to N4
- More sophisticated node at smaller volume
- N4 has more process steps than N28, less forgiving tolerances
- TSMC prefers conservative approach: start easier, work up technology chain
Joint Venture Structure and Benefits
- JASM ownership: TSMC 86.5%, Sony 6%, Denso 5.5%, Toyota 2%
- Partners provide three key benefits:
- Guaranteed demand and volume from customers
- Supplier network access through Sony connections
- Local community facilitation (land acquisition, water supply management)
- Arizona: TSMC working alone, no local partner
- Potential US partners (GlobalFoundries, Intel) are fierce competitors
- Japanese government played matchmaker role, insisted Sony involvement
Subsidy Timing and Conditions
- Japan subsidies: $3.5 billion (40% of fab cost)
- Announced June 2022, payments started end of 2022
- Looser conditions: 10-year commitment, output increases during shortages, technology safeguards
- US CHIPS Act: signed August 2022, amounts not yet announced
- Office employs 130+ people for extensive vetting
- Wider-ranging "guard rails" including China/Russia expansion restrictions
- More complex compliance requirements for TSMC's mainland fabs
Labor Market Dynamics
- Kumamoto historically major semiconductor center, now economically depressed
- Minimum wage among Japan's lowest
- 40% high school graduates leave for work elsewhere
- TSMC wage premium: jobs paying 30,000 yen now pay 50,000 yen
- Engineer salaries 33% higher than market rates
- Kumamoto fab estimated 1,500 employees
- US challenges: semiconductor manufacturing worker shortage after years of inactivity
- Intel Ohio: 40% workers brought from out of state
- Cultural differences: Taiwan/Japan emphasize long tenure vs US worker fluidity
Cultural and Labor Relations Issues
- TSMC requires extended Taiwan training program for new workers
- High dropout rate from training program
- Intel offers competing alternative with higher wages, better conditions
- Morris Chang clearly anti-union, company avoids unionization
- Arizona union conflict: unions opposed Taiwanese worker visas for equipment installation
- Union leader accused TSMC of replacing Americans with "cheaper Taiwanese"
- December 2023: deal reached between TSMC and unions
Regulatory and Environmental Challenges
- Taiwan example: Kaohsiung city cleared administrative procedures in single day
- US among slowest places globally to build fabs
- Fab builds declined from 55 (1990s) to 22 currently, none large-scale
- Delays from: material shortages, labor shortages, transportation issues
- Environmental permits: pollutant discharge, asbestos, waste transport, storm water
- Multiple agencies handle permits, coordination difficult
- Local requirements vary significantly by location
CHIPS Act Assessment and Future Outlook
- 2022 CHIPS Act predicted to be qualified public success
- TSMC will play secondary role in success
- Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo targeting: 0% to 20% US share of leading-edge digital logic chips
- Intel likely primary beneficiary as "American national champion"
- Intel 18A node will establish technological leadership
- TSMC Arizona future depends on subsidy size
- If seeking 40% support like Japan: $16 billion subsidy on $40 billion project
- Political challenge: giving $16 billion taxpayer money to foreign company in election year
- Investment tax credits will provide some subsidy relief
- Without adequate subsidies: likely end after Phase 2, no Phase 3
- TSMC will expand in Japan instead, settling Taiwan chip supply concerns
