AI summary by TwinMind

Why is TSMC Doing Better in Japan?

Asianometry

19m 55s

TSMC Fab Development Timeline Comparison

  • TSMC Japan (JASM) announced November 2021, launched February 2024 ceremony
    • 20 months from announcement to fab start
    • Morris Chang gave speech, Japanese government announced support for second phase
    • Rumors of third phase in development
  • TSMC Arizona announced May 2020, still under construction
    • Second phase size depends on CHIPS Act subsidies
    • Chips from second phase not expected until 2028
    • Added last steel beam February 2024

Semiconductor Fab Complexity

  • Fabrication facility = ultimate expression of haste and unforgiving precision
  • Process flow: hundreds of steps over many months
    • Major functions: oxidation, deposition, photolithography, ion implant, metalization, cleaning
    • Up to 500 tools in clean room environment
  • Global average: 1.9 years construction to production start
  • Single fab costs tens of billions in capital investment
  • TSMC pledged $40 billion for two Arizona phases
  • Tools rapidly depreciate, only viable at nearly 100% utilization

Geographic and Logistical Factors

  • Taiwan-Japan distance: 1-2 hour flight vs 12-14 hour flight to US
  • Kumamoto on Kyushu island, geographically close to Taiwan
  • Distance delays urgent responses, stretches suppliers beyond previous limits
  • Precedent exists: Japanese car companies (Toyota, Honda) successfully transplanted culture to US
  • Intel successfully built advanced fabs in Ireland and Israel

Technology Node Differences

  • Japan JASM processes:
    • Phase 1: 28nm, 22nm technology, 16nm/12nm FinFET node
    • Phase 2: N6 (7nm class process)
    • Rumored Phase 3: N4 or better
  • Arizona processes:
    • Started with N5 (5nm node), upgraded to N4
    • More sophisticated node at smaller volume
  • N4 has more process steps than N28, less forgiving tolerances
  • TSMC prefers conservative approach: start easier, work up technology chain

Joint Venture Structure and Benefits

  • JASM ownership: TSMC 86.5%, Sony 6%, Denso 5.5%, Toyota 2%
  • Partners provide three key benefits:
    • Guaranteed demand and volume from customers
    • Supplier network access through Sony connections
    • Local community facilitation (land acquisition, water supply management)
  • Arizona: TSMC working alone, no local partner
  • Potential US partners (GlobalFoundries, Intel) are fierce competitors
  • Japanese government played matchmaker role, insisted Sony involvement

Subsidy Timing and Conditions

  • Japan subsidies: $3.5 billion (40% of fab cost)
    • Announced June 2022, payments started end of 2022
    • Looser conditions: 10-year commitment, output increases during shortages, technology safeguards
  • US CHIPS Act: signed August 2022, amounts not yet announced
    • Office employs 130+ people for extensive vetting
    • Wider-ranging "guard rails" including China/Russia expansion restrictions
    • More complex compliance requirements for TSMC's mainland fabs

Labor Market Dynamics

  • Kumamoto historically major semiconductor center, now economically depressed
    • Minimum wage among Japan's lowest
    • 40% high school graduates leave for work elsewhere
  • TSMC wage premium: jobs paying 30,000 yen now pay 50,000 yen
  • Engineer salaries 33% higher than market rates
  • Kumamoto fab estimated 1,500 employees
  • US challenges: semiconductor manufacturing worker shortage after years of inactivity
  • Intel Ohio: 40% workers brought from out of state
  • Cultural differences: Taiwan/Japan emphasize long tenure vs US worker fluidity

Cultural and Labor Relations Issues

  • TSMC requires extended Taiwan training program for new workers
  • High dropout rate from training program
  • Intel offers competing alternative with higher wages, better conditions
  • Morris Chang clearly anti-union, company avoids unionization
  • Arizona union conflict: unions opposed Taiwanese worker visas for equipment installation
  • Union leader accused TSMC of replacing Americans with "cheaper Taiwanese"
  • December 2023: deal reached between TSMC and unions

Regulatory and Environmental Challenges

  • Taiwan example: Kaohsiung city cleared administrative procedures in single day
  • US among slowest places globally to build fabs
  • Fab builds declined from 55 (1990s) to 22 currently, none large-scale
  • Delays from: material shortages, labor shortages, transportation issues
  • Environmental permits: pollutant discharge, asbestos, waste transport, storm water
  • Multiple agencies handle permits, coordination difficult
  • Local requirements vary significantly by location

CHIPS Act Assessment and Future Outlook

  • 2022 CHIPS Act predicted to be qualified public success
  • TSMC will play secondary role in success
  • Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo targeting: 0% to 20% US share of leading-edge digital logic chips
  • Intel likely primary beneficiary as "American national champion"
  • Intel 18A node will establish technological leadership
  • TSMC Arizona future depends on subsidy size
  • If seeking 40% support like Japan: $16 billion subsidy on $40 billion project
  • Political challenge: giving $16 billion taxpayer money to foreign company in election year
  • Investment tax credits will provide some subsidy relief
  • Without adequate subsidies: likely end after Phase 2, no Phase 3
  • TSMC will expand in Japan instead, settling Taiwan chip supply concerns

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome