AI summary by TwinMind
Why it’s Illegal to Buy a Car from Toyota
PolyMatter
13m 54s
Kellogg, Idaho Car Dealership Anomaly
- Population: 2,255, Dave Smith Motors employs 400 people
- More cars on lot than town residents on given day
- Brand new $70,000-$100,000 Ford Super Duties in area with $35,000 median household income (30% less than Mississippi)
- 12,000 people within 20-mile radius, closest major airport Spokane 1+ hour away
- Nation's largest Jeep Ram dealer location
- Town drive-through takes 2.5 minutes: diner, post office, hardware store
- City hall/police station/zoning department in single shack, 81-year-old mayor
US Dealer Franchise Laws Overview
- Unlike Apple/Sony/Samsung, Ford/Toyota/Honda cannot open own stores
- Cars must be sold by middlemen with regional exclusivity
- Average Toyota dealer Boston area: $6 million profit annually
- 20% of all dealer owners make $1.5+ million yearly
Historical Context (1949-1980s)
- 1949: US population 45% of today's, nearly 50,000 dealerships (3x current number)
- Small mom-and-pop operations serving local communities
- "Big Three" carmakers: Ford, General Motors, Chrysler
- Extreme power imbalance: carmakers controlled dealers, forced unpopular model purchases
- All 50 states stepped in to protect dealers
- Illegal to force unwanted car purchases
- Carmakers couldn't undercut dealer prices via direct sales
- Laws shifted risk back to manufacturers
- Carmakers can only terminate franchise for specific reasons (fraud)
- Must compensate dealers for future profits, rent, unsold inventory
Internet Era Transformation
- Dealers initially paralyzed by internet competition
- Lobbied for additional government protection
- Created new winners from small, remote locations
- Dave Smith Motors opened 1965 during Idaho silver boom
- Silver price crash 1980s forced adaptation unlike complacent larger dealers
- Internet opportunity: cheap Idaho land/labor enabled price competition
- Customers flew from Alaska/Florida, shuttle bus from Spokane to Kellogg
Corporate Consolidation
- Dave Smith now part of Sonic Automotive (5th largest dealer)
- Lithia Motors #1 auto group nationally
- 679,000 cars sold annually (1,800/day)
- 2020: acquired new dealership every 5 days
- 2020-2022: doubled annual revenue
- Started in Ashland, Oregon (6,000 population)
- Average dealership: $71 million annual sales
- New car prices increased 40% (2015-2022) due to dealer mark-ups
Current Market Power
- Lithia Motors: $30 billion revenue (exceeds Subaru $28 billion, Mazda worldwide revenue)
- Dealers employ ~100 people average (Nevada/Arizona)
- Car sales: 20% of state sales taxes
- National Dealers Association: powerful lobbying group
- Every state legislator has dealership in district
- Dealers sponsor Little League, donate to Meals on Wheels, support local newspapers
Electric Vehicle Challenge
- Tesla entered 2013, refused dealer sales model
- Dealers biased against EVs: 40% less aftermarket revenue (parts/service)
- Consumer Reports secret shoppers: 35/85 dealerships advised against EVs
- State-by-state responses:
- Michigan: showrooms/test drives only, sales out-of-state
- Texas: export/re-import requirement, no price mentions
- Connecticut: lease only, no purchases
- New Mexico: tribal land dealerships
- Ohio: 3 Tesla dealerships maximum
Industry Transformation
- Ford/Volvo announced online sales plans
- Hyundai selling on Amazon soon
- Traditional price negotiations declining
- Dealer monopoly weakening after century
