AI summary by TwinMind

Why “Learn to Code” Failed

PolyMatter

25m 26s

UC Berkeley Computer Science Explosion (2011-2021)

  • CS graduates increased by 1,116% between 2011-2021
  • At current trend, all 30,000 undergrads would study CS in 7 years
  • By 2029, would produce more CS graduates than California's population
  • Fewer software developers employed in US today than 6 years ago

University CS Dominance Statistics

  • Berkeley not most CS-obsessed university
  • MIT: 40% of students study same subject
  • MIT 2023 graduates: 7 chemistry majors vs 266 CS&E majors
  • Electrical Engineering & CS twice as popular as CS&E alone
  • Berkeley, MIT, Cornell created dedicated computing colleges in 2023
  • First new school since Eisenhower presidency

"Learn to Code" Cultural Movement Origins

  • iPhone released 2007, followed by Uber, Airbnb, Instagram
  • Cultural shift from Wall Street to Bay Area tech
  • Shows like Social Network, Silicon Valley mythologized tech founders
  • Obama called coding "ticket to middle class"
  • White House promoted Computer Science Education Week, Hour of Code
  • Warned of 1 million STEM graduate shortfall by 2022
  • Bloomberg announced learning to code in 2012 (no evidence he did)

Political Appeal of "Learn to Code"

  • Republicans: aligned with vocational education vision
  • Corporations: steady supply of pre-trained labor at taxpayer expense
  • National security: strengthen America vs China competition
  • Diversity advocates: expanding opportunity narrative
  • Democrats: empowering solution during Great Recession
  • Addressed globalization concerns: layoffs, automation, outsourcing

K-12 Implementation

  • Nearly 15,000 US high schools offer CS classes
  • 37% of middle schools offer CS classes
  • 11 states require CS class for graduation
  • Red and blue states adopted Python/JavaScript curricula

University Infrastructure Crisis

  • Total undergraduate CS students tripled in 10 years
  • PhD students becoming professors stayed constant
  • PhD stipend: $40,000/year vs $200,000+ at Amazon/Netflix
  • Result: impersonal factory-like CS departments
  • Class sizes: 400-600 students in introductory courses
  • Undergrads deputized as TAs
  • Universities require reapplication to CS programs after 1-2 years

Lottery System Examples

  • Swarthmore, University of Maryland, UCSD use lottery systems
  • Students pay $90,000+/year at Swarthmore, can be denied major by random number
  • Students graduate with debt, minimal professor contact
  • Inadequate job market preparation
  • CS curricula focus on algorithms/theory vs marketable syntax/languages
  • Graduates dabble in multiple languages but master none

Coding Bootcamp Rise

  • Solution to university problems: 6-figure Amazon jobs
  • Cost: $10,000-$30,000 for 12 weeks or less
  • Stripped general education, taught to tech interview tests
  • Peak: hundreds of bootcamps graduated nearly half as many as 4-year programs
  • Revenue: north of $200 million/year

Bootcamp Challenges

  • Students' performance affected bootcamp reputation
  • Silicon Valley small world: most target same 5 companies
  • Hack Reactor: 3% acceptance rate (same as Harvard)
  • Teacher shortage: competed with big tech salaries
  • Hired recent graduates who couldn't find work elsewhere
  • Pressure to raise tuition as costs increased

University-Bootcamp Partnership Model

  • 2011 Department of Education loophole created
  • Universities could pay third parties if part of larger service bundle
  • Online Program Manager (OPM) partnerships emerged
  • OPMs created curriculum, hired teachers, recruited students
  • Universities provided name recognition for 40% cut
  • Bootcamps gained access to federal student loans through accreditation

Tech Industry Boom Period

  • Pandemic era: explosive tech growth
  • Companies hoarded labor aggressively
  • 2023 Wall Street Journal: Meta paid woman $190,000/year "to do almost nothing"
  • Aggressive hiring rewarded by investors
  • Competition for talent fierce

Tech Industry Crash

  • 2023: nearly 500,000 tech workers laid off
  • 2022: 250,000 laid off
  • 2024: another 250,000 laid off
  • Total: ~1 million layoffs (equivalent to early 2000s China shock manufacturing losses)
  • Tech unemployment rate now higher than national average
  • Berkeley professors report best students can't find jobs
  • Recent graduates had offers rescinded

Bootcamp Industry Collapse

  • 2U declared bankruptcy
  • Launch Academy paused enrollment
  • Dev Boot Camp (acquired by Kaplan) closed permanently
  • Most bootcamps no longer exist

Economic Analysis

  • Interest rates rose from ~0% to 5%+ in 2022
  • Tech industry unusually exposed to borrowing costs
  • Software requires massive upfront investment
  • Oversupply of programmers made workers expendable
  • Employers treat programmers as "spigot" - on/off demand vs long-term investment

Future Projections vs Reality

  • Bureau of Labor Statistics: 11% growth in computer occupations by 2033
  • White House predicted 1 million STEM shortfall by 2022
  • Reality: fewer software developers than 6 years ago
  • Current tech employment: ~1.9 million (2.3% of US labor force even if doubled)
  • Programming couldn't absorb 7 million unemployed Americans

Fundamental Misconceptions

  • 2012 article compared coding to reading/writing
  • Belief everyone would need to program (electricians, teachers, insurance adjusters)
  • 1,000% growth seemed reasonable under universal skill premise
  • Reality: programming is specialized career among many
  • Tech as volatile as other industries
  • AI rise demonstrates continued volatility

Human Diversity Ignored

  • Not everyone suited for/enjoys programming
  • Office work, sitting all day, computer focus, teamwork, deadline pressure
  • Single mothers, laid-off factory workers, 18-year-olds treated as interchangeable
  • Bootcamps promised $150,000 salaries for all backgrounds
  • Minimal support for non-traditional students
  • Former contractors struggled vs peers with coding experience
  • Students blamed themselves when told coding was "easy"

Real-World Outcomes

  • Many graduated with $20,000 debt, 3 months lost wages
  • Bootcamp resume line worked against some applicants
  • Even successful graduates vulnerable to layoffs
  • Amazon laid off 18,000 employees January 5, 2023
  • "Learn to code" no more magic than "learn wind turbine service" or "learn occupational therapy"
  • Occupational therapy demand: 60% growth expected
  • Wind turbine service: 22% growth expected (both faster than software)

Alternative Approach

  • Invest in non-industry-specific skills
  • Problem-solving, critical thinking, adaptability
  • Higher-level skills vs specific programming languages
  • Programming languages come and go
  • Process-focused learning vs outcome-focused

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome