AI summary by TwinMind
Why Losing SWIFT Matters
Asianometry
14m 48s
SWIFT Overview and Function
- Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT)
- Provides financial messaging services to 11,000 banks worldwide
- Cooperative organization, not company - arose to replace outdated technology
- Crucial part of global financial system
- Enables correspondent banking (co-banking) - banks hold deposits/provide payment services for other banks
- Functions like "WhatsApp for banks" - no money sent, just transaction information
- Each bank has public SWIFT code for error-free fund transfers
- 100+ standard formats for different financial services
- MT-103: most common format for customer fund transfers between financial institutions
- 11,000+ financial institutions across 200+ areas signed up
- 2020 statistics: averaged 40 million messages/day, 9.5 billion total messages
Historical Evolution of Banking Communications
- Early co-banking agreements executed via paper/post
- Late 1840s: electrical telegraph enabled faster distant market communications
- 1866: first transatlantic submarine cable integrated NY/London stock markets
- End of 1800s: global networks connected Australia-Europe-America banks
- Global economy emerged with unrestricted capital flows
- Two world wars restricted capital markets to national borders
Telex Era (Pre-SWIFT)
- Interwar period: typewriter keyboard and first teleprinter exchanges (telex networks)
- Telex: privileged teleprinter network for back-and-forth text messaging
- Emerged in Germany pre-WWII, spread quickly
- Banks/stock exchanges among first adopters ("wires")
- Replaced telegraph for business subscribers
- 1957: 30,000 subscribers across Europe, Americas, Africa, Asia
- 1970s: estimated 1 million users worldwide
Telex Limitations
- Authentication issues: messages sent via unsecured public telegraph/telephone networks
- Complicated manual authentication procedures with test keys (time-consuming)
- No standardized message format - prone to errors
- Slow: 8 bytes/second transmission speed
- Required average 10 messages per transaction
- Hundreds/thousands daily messages made system impractical for modern banking
SWIFT Development and Launch
- Banks began building proprietary networks
- Citibank first with Machine-Readable Telegraphic Input (MARTI)
- MARTI: proprietary network Citibank attempted to impose industry-wide
- Other banks concerned about Citibank dominance
- 1970: 68 European/US banks founded International Message Switching Project (MSP)
- 1973: MSP became SWIFT, established in Brussels
- 239 banks from 15 countries as founding members
- May 1977: first SWIFT message sent
- Same year: MARTI closed down, losing to SWIFT's cooperative value proposition
SWIFT Growth and Dominance
- Next 20 years: broad adoption for high-value international financial transactions
- 2020: world sent $140 trillion worth of cross-border transmissions
- 90% of cross-border transactions initiated via SWIFT
- Network built over 50 years, sits on century-old banking habits
- Continues modernizing while facing competition
SWIFT Competitors and Alternatives
Private Remittance Companies
- US-based Remitly, Taiwan-based EMQ
- Target working individuals/smaller companies
- SWIFT pricing barrier: $200,000 initial connection + $10,000 annual
- Opens room for small remittance players
Cryptocurrency
- Ripple: 6th largest cryptocurrency by market cap
- Offers competing service to SWIFT
National Networks
- China's CIPS (Cross-border Interbank Payment System)
- Launched 2015
- 2016: connected to SWIFT network via memorandum of understanding
- Focus: facilitating cross-border RMB business for trade vs financial messaging
- Constrained by Beijing's strict capital controls post-2014
Russia's SPFS
- System for Transfer of Financial Messages
- Launched 2014 after Crimea sanctions threat
- 2014: US/Europe considered removing Russia from SWIFT
- SWIFT objected, highlighted neutral global messaging provider status
- Removal never happened, but Russia's central bank called for alternative
Sanctions and SWIFT as Weapon
Historical Context
- Countries sanctioning each other since Pericles sanctioned Megarians (432 BC)
- 1990s: broad UN sanctions on Iraq after Gulf War
- Failed because harmed civilians rather than regime elites
- Led to development of "smart sanctions" targeting financial/government elite
Iran Case Study (2007-2015)
- US intensified financial sanctions against Iran for nuclear program
- Started 2007: froze assets of country's 4th largest bank
- Culminated 2012: Iran removed from SWIFT (only time until now)
- Obama administration: "smart sanctions" more precise than traditional trade sanctions
Iran Economic Impact
- Banking/finance <3% of Iranian economy, but costs fell on ordinary Iranians
- Sanctions cost Iran ~16% of total GDP
- First year: GDP decreased $75.5 billion USD
- Lost 50% oil exports, 30% total exports
- 6,000 production enterprises affected
- 67% of economy fell into financial distress
- 2012-2015: cumulative cost = 2/3 of entire economy
- Comparable to US experience in 2009 global financial crisis
Iranian Workarounds
- Accepted hard assets like gold
- U-turn scheme loophole: foreigners could buy Iranian oil with dollars
- Options not available to everyone
- 2015 JCPOA negotiations: SWIFT return was key incentive
- Trump administration pulled back, Iran economy hasn't recovered
European Alternative: INSTEX
- Instrument in Support of Trade Exchanges
- Set up by European banks for non-USD transactions with Iran
- Outside oil/gas sector
- Mostly for medicines, pistachios, carpets
- Little overall impact, mostly curiosity
Russian Preparation and SPFS System
- Russian federation relies on SWIFT for billions in hydrocarbon sales payments
- 2014 forecasts: SWIFT cutoff would cost Russia ≥5% GDP
- Concluded Iran's vulnerability due to lack of timely SWIFT alternative
- SPFS runs parallel with SWIFT as backup system
- 2018: 355 Russian banks connected to SPFS
- Current: ~400 banks including foreign banks (UniCredit, Deutsche Bank)
- 2020: ~13 million messages annually, 20% domestic market share
- Russian officials promote SPFS abroad but limited foreign adoption
SPFS Technical Limitations
- Messages limited to 20 kilobytes
- Only works during normal business hours
- Immaturity/lack of competitiveness means SWIFT removal would still trigger massive capital outflows/currency volatility
Russian Financial Infrastructure Alternatives
MIR Credit Card System
- Parallel credit card clearing system within Russia
- "MIR" means "world"
- 73 million issued bank cards, 24% market share
- Standard issue for pensioners, public sector employees
- Not easily accepted abroad
- Co-brand deals with China's UnionPay and Japanese JCB
Analysis and Conclusions
- No global SWIFT alternative coming soon
- Removal effects can be ameliorated medium-term
- SWIFT remains crucial as long as banks matter globally
- Shouldn't be first tool for imposing punishments
- Leads countries to seek alternatives, concerns about dedollarization
- Should be implemented as part of "united front" approach
- Need to deal with countries buying energy rather than payment channels
- Losing SWIFT has great economic impact even with backup systems
- No more "smart targeting" - entire country/people feel impact
- Hopefully such punishment only temporary
