AI summary by TwinMind

Why Losing SWIFT Matters

Asianometry

14m 48s

SWIFT Overview and Function

  • Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT)
  • Provides financial messaging services to 11,000 banks worldwide
  • Cooperative organization, not company - arose to replace outdated technology
  • Crucial part of global financial system
  • Enables correspondent banking (co-banking) - banks hold deposits/provide payment services for other banks
  • Functions like "WhatsApp for banks" - no money sent, just transaction information
  • Each bank has public SWIFT code for error-free fund transfers
  • 100+ standard formats for different financial services
    • MT-103: most common format for customer fund transfers between financial institutions
  • 11,000+ financial institutions across 200+ areas signed up
  • 2020 statistics: averaged 40 million messages/day, 9.5 billion total messages

Historical Evolution of Banking Communications

  • Early co-banking agreements executed via paper/post
  • Late 1840s: electrical telegraph enabled faster distant market communications
  • 1866: first transatlantic submarine cable integrated NY/London stock markets
  • End of 1800s: global networks connected Australia-Europe-America banks
  • Global economy emerged with unrestricted capital flows
  • Two world wars restricted capital markets to national borders

Telex Era (Pre-SWIFT)

  • Interwar period: typewriter keyboard and first teleprinter exchanges (telex networks)
  • Telex: privileged teleprinter network for back-and-forth text messaging
  • Emerged in Germany pre-WWII, spread quickly
  • Banks/stock exchanges among first adopters ("wires")
  • Replaced telegraph for business subscribers
  • 1957: 30,000 subscribers across Europe, Americas, Africa, Asia
  • 1970s: estimated 1 million users worldwide

Telex Limitations

  • Authentication issues: messages sent via unsecured public telegraph/telephone networks
  • Complicated manual authentication procedures with test keys (time-consuming)
  • No standardized message format - prone to errors
  • Slow: 8 bytes/second transmission speed
  • Required average 10 messages per transaction
  • Hundreds/thousands daily messages made system impractical for modern banking

SWIFT Development and Launch

  • Banks began building proprietary networks
  • Citibank first with Machine-Readable Telegraphic Input (MARTI)
  • MARTI: proprietary network Citibank attempted to impose industry-wide
  • Other banks concerned about Citibank dominance
  • 1970: 68 European/US banks founded International Message Switching Project (MSP)
  • 1973: MSP became SWIFT, established in Brussels
  • 239 banks from 15 countries as founding members
  • May 1977: first SWIFT message sent
  • Same year: MARTI closed down, losing to SWIFT's cooperative value proposition

SWIFT Growth and Dominance

  • Next 20 years: broad adoption for high-value international financial transactions
  • 2020: world sent $140 trillion worth of cross-border transmissions
  • 90% of cross-border transactions initiated via SWIFT
  • Network built over 50 years, sits on century-old banking habits
  • Continues modernizing while facing competition

SWIFT Competitors and Alternatives

Private Remittance Companies

  • US-based Remitly, Taiwan-based EMQ
  • Target working individuals/smaller companies
  • SWIFT pricing barrier: $200,000 initial connection + $10,000 annual
  • Opens room for small remittance players

Cryptocurrency

  • Ripple: 6th largest cryptocurrency by market cap
  • Offers competing service to SWIFT

National Networks

  • China's CIPS (Cross-border Interbank Payment System)
    • Launched 2015
    • 2016: connected to SWIFT network via memorandum of understanding
    • Focus: facilitating cross-border RMB business for trade vs financial messaging
    • Constrained by Beijing's strict capital controls post-2014

Russia's SPFS

  • System for Transfer of Financial Messages
  • Launched 2014 after Crimea sanctions threat
  • 2014: US/Europe considered removing Russia from SWIFT
  • SWIFT objected, highlighted neutral global messaging provider status
  • Removal never happened, but Russia's central bank called for alternative

Sanctions and SWIFT as Weapon

Historical Context

  • Countries sanctioning each other since Pericles sanctioned Megarians (432 BC)
  • 1990s: broad UN sanctions on Iraq after Gulf War
  • Failed because harmed civilians rather than regime elites
  • Led to development of "smart sanctions" targeting financial/government elite

Iran Case Study (2007-2015)

  • US intensified financial sanctions against Iran for nuclear program
  • Started 2007: froze assets of country's 4th largest bank
  • Culminated 2012: Iran removed from SWIFT (only time until now)
  • Obama administration: "smart sanctions" more precise than traditional trade sanctions

Iran Economic Impact

  • Banking/finance <3% of Iranian economy, but costs fell on ordinary Iranians
  • Sanctions cost Iran ~16% of total GDP
  • First year: GDP decreased $75.5 billion USD
  • Lost 50% oil exports, 30% total exports
  • 6,000 production enterprises affected
  • 67% of economy fell into financial distress
  • 2012-2015: cumulative cost = 2/3 of entire economy
  • Comparable to US experience in 2009 global financial crisis

Iranian Workarounds

  • Accepted hard assets like gold
  • U-turn scheme loophole: foreigners could buy Iranian oil with dollars
  • Options not available to everyone
  • 2015 JCPOA negotiations: SWIFT return was key incentive
  • Trump administration pulled back, Iran economy hasn't recovered

European Alternative: INSTEX

  • Instrument in Support of Trade Exchanges
  • Set up by European banks for non-USD transactions with Iran
  • Outside oil/gas sector
  • Mostly for medicines, pistachios, carpets
  • Little overall impact, mostly curiosity

Russian Preparation and SPFS System

  • Russian federation relies on SWIFT for billions in hydrocarbon sales payments
  • 2014 forecasts: SWIFT cutoff would cost Russia ≥5% GDP
  • Concluded Iran's vulnerability due to lack of timely SWIFT alternative
  • SPFS runs parallel with SWIFT as backup system
  • 2018: 355 Russian banks connected to SPFS
  • Current: ~400 banks including foreign banks (UniCredit, Deutsche Bank)
  • 2020: ~13 million messages annually, 20% domestic market share
  • Russian officials promote SPFS abroad but limited foreign adoption

SPFS Technical Limitations

  • Messages limited to 20 kilobytes
  • Only works during normal business hours
  • Immaturity/lack of competitiveness means SWIFT removal would still trigger massive capital outflows/currency volatility

Russian Financial Infrastructure Alternatives

MIR Credit Card System

  • Parallel credit card clearing system within Russia
  • "MIR" means "world"
  • 73 million issued bank cards, 24% market share
  • Standard issue for pensioners, public sector employees
  • Not easily accepted abroad
  • Co-brand deals with China's UnionPay and Japanese JCB

Analysis and Conclusions

  • No global SWIFT alternative coming soon
  • Removal effects can be ameliorated medium-term
  • SWIFT remains crucial as long as banks matter globally
  • Shouldn't be first tool for imposing punishments
  • Leads countries to seek alternatives, concerns about dedollarization
  • Should be implemented as part of "united front" approach
  • Need to deal with countries buying energy rather than payment channels
  • Losing SWIFT has great economic impact even with backup systems
  • No more "smart targeting" - entire country/people feel impact
  • Hopefully such punishment only temporary

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome