AI summary by TwinMind

Why Middle Managers Will Outlast Us All

How Money Works

10m 22s

Corporate Efficiency vs Middle Management Paradox

  • Companies supposed to maximize profit through efficiency
  • Yet many bloated with middle management layers
  • Universal hatred/ridicule of middle managers
  • Activist investors consistently target middle management cuts for profitability
  • Hierarchical structures (VPs, managers, team leaders) falling out of fashion
  • Tech companies pioneered flat structures, now worth trillions
  • Dunder Mifflin example: sales branch reporting to CFO (misaligned roles)

Research on Flattening Corporate Hierarchies

  • Wharton School survey: 300 major American companies
  • Corporate hierarchies getting flatter with fewer positions between CEO and entry-level
  • Fewer management layers between top and bottom

Reason 1: Middle Management Actually Important

  • Management hierarchies adapted from military command structures
  • Wharton research: flat structures led to underperforming business in startups
  • Flat organizations less agile than hierarchical companies
  • Large teams prone to meaningless collaboration vs achieving objectives
  • Management spread too thin without adequate oversight
  • Managers with 6+ direct reports under senior managers with 6+ reports:
    • Less capacity and pressure for close monitoring
    • Higher likelihood of underperformance, malpractice, fraud going unnoticed
  • Failed companies with flat structures: Theranos, FTX, WeWork
  • Smaller organized teams enable easier feedback, permissions, face-time with boss
  • Compounding effect example:
    • 6 employees under 1 manager = 15 different arrangements (difficult planning)
    • 2 middle managers with 2 analysts each = 1 clear arrangement
    • Average manager oversight: 6 employees vs 2 employees
  • Adding one management layer provides significant organizational benefits

Reason 2: Middle Managers as Motivation Tools

  • Motivate staff through rewards for hard workers, punishment for slackers
  • Even useless middle managers motivate advancement-seeking employees
  • 2022 Pew Research workplace survey findings:
    • 2nd most common reason for leaving jobs: no advancement opportunities
    • Almost equal to those leaving due to low pay
  • Flat structures = fewer senior positions, more peer competition
  • Adding managers reduces staffing costs through lower turnover
  • Hiring costs per Society for Human Resource Management:
    • $4,700 average cost to advertise job opening
    • Up to 3x position salary for full onboarding (soft costs included)
  • Additional hiring burdens: background checks, onboarding, training time
  • Internal promotions cheaper than external hires
  • Employees changing companies every 2 years earn 50% more than long-term stayers
  • Managers earn more than non-managers but less than new external hires

Reason 3: Middle Managers Control Hiring/Firing

  • Two types of large company layoffs:
    1. Top-down restructuring targeting senior leadership
    2. Reduction in force (bottom-up cuts)
  • Fortune 500 CEO statistics:
    • Average tenure: 5 years
    • 71% fired, 28% left on own terms, 1% died in position
    • Average age: 58
  • Senior managers fired during acquisitions/mergers (redundant C-suite)
  • Reduction in force decisions delegated to middle managers
  • Middle managers know strong/weak performers on teams
  • Middle managers last targeted during layoffs
  • Full-time employee status makes individual firing harder

Why Middle Managers Face Ridicule

  • Companies hire middle managers for wrong reasons:

Wrong Reason 1: Managing Processes Instead of People

  • Should be one-stop contact for subordinates
  • Bad example: sales team with separate managers for performance, benefits, training
  • Creates confusion over who to contact
  • "Matrix organization" and "dotted line reporting" = red flags

Wrong Reason 2: Rewarding Good Employees Unnecessarily

  • McKinsey survey: middle managers wasted when no managerial need exists
  • End up doing same work as team below them
  • Causes dissatisfaction and higher job stress (working two jobs)
  • New management positions require existing managers to give up power
  • Management titles without agency confuse subordinates

Wrong Reason 3: Dilbert Principle

  • High-performing employee promoted until incompetent at new role
  • No longer high-performing, so no further promotions
  • Spend career doing job they're not good at
  • More people declining promotions to avoid stress
  • Some taking advantage of low-stress remote work or multiple jobs
  • Employees earning more with less stress than their managers
  • Management becoming harder skill to fill due to lifestyle preferences

Future of Middle Management

  • Middle management roles easy to create, hard to eliminate as companies age
  • Despite ridicule, it's hard, underappreciated but always needed job
  • Management as unique skill becoming scarcer due to work-life balance priorities

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome