AI summary by TwinMind
Why Middle Managers Will Outlast Us All
How Money Works
10m 22s
Corporate Efficiency vs Middle Management Paradox
- Companies supposed to maximize profit through efficiency
- Yet many bloated with middle management layers
- Universal hatred/ridicule of middle managers
- Activist investors consistently target middle management cuts for profitability
- Hierarchical structures (VPs, managers, team leaders) falling out of fashion
- Tech companies pioneered flat structures, now worth trillions
- Dunder Mifflin example: sales branch reporting to CFO (misaligned roles)
Research on Flattening Corporate Hierarchies
- Wharton School survey: 300 major American companies
- Corporate hierarchies getting flatter with fewer positions between CEO and entry-level
- Fewer management layers between top and bottom
Reason 1: Middle Management Actually Important
- Management hierarchies adapted from military command structures
- Wharton research: flat structures led to underperforming business in startups
- Flat organizations less agile than hierarchical companies
- Large teams prone to meaningless collaboration vs achieving objectives
- Management spread too thin without adequate oversight
- Managers with 6+ direct reports under senior managers with 6+ reports:
- Less capacity and pressure for close monitoring
- Higher likelihood of underperformance, malpractice, fraud going unnoticed
- Failed companies with flat structures: Theranos, FTX, WeWork
- Smaller organized teams enable easier feedback, permissions, face-time with boss
- Compounding effect example:
- 6 employees under 1 manager = 15 different arrangements (difficult planning)
- 2 middle managers with 2 analysts each = 1 clear arrangement
- Average manager oversight: 6 employees vs 2 employees
- Adding one management layer provides significant organizational benefits
Reason 2: Middle Managers as Motivation Tools
- Motivate staff through rewards for hard workers, punishment for slackers
- Even useless middle managers motivate advancement-seeking employees
- 2022 Pew Research workplace survey findings:
- 2nd most common reason for leaving jobs: no advancement opportunities
- Almost equal to those leaving due to low pay
- Flat structures = fewer senior positions, more peer competition
- Adding managers reduces staffing costs through lower turnover
- Hiring costs per Society for Human Resource Management:
- $4,700 average cost to advertise job opening
- Up to 3x position salary for full onboarding (soft costs included)
- Additional hiring burdens: background checks, onboarding, training time
- Internal promotions cheaper than external hires
- Employees changing companies every 2 years earn 50% more than long-term stayers
- Managers earn more than non-managers but less than new external hires
Reason 3: Middle Managers Control Hiring/Firing
- Two types of large company layoffs:
- Top-down restructuring targeting senior leadership
- Reduction in force (bottom-up cuts)
- Fortune 500 CEO statistics:
- Average tenure: 5 years
- 71% fired, 28% left on own terms, 1% died in position
- Average age: 58
- Senior managers fired during acquisitions/mergers (redundant C-suite)
- Reduction in force decisions delegated to middle managers
- Middle managers know strong/weak performers on teams
- Middle managers last targeted during layoffs
- Full-time employee status makes individual firing harder
Why Middle Managers Face Ridicule
- Companies hire middle managers for wrong reasons:
Wrong Reason 1: Managing Processes Instead of People
- Should be one-stop contact for subordinates
- Bad example: sales team with separate managers for performance, benefits, training
- Creates confusion over who to contact
- "Matrix organization" and "dotted line reporting" = red flags
Wrong Reason 2: Rewarding Good Employees Unnecessarily
- McKinsey survey: middle managers wasted when no managerial need exists
- End up doing same work as team below them
- Causes dissatisfaction and higher job stress (working two jobs)
- New management positions require existing managers to give up power
- Management titles without agency confuse subordinates
Wrong Reason 3: Dilbert Principle
- High-performing employee promoted until incompetent at new role
- No longer high-performing, so no further promotions
- Spend career doing job they're not good at
- More people declining promotions to avoid stress
- Some taking advantage of low-stress remote work or multiple jobs
- Employees earning more with less stress than their managers
- Management becoming harder skill to fill due to lifestyle preferences
Future of Middle Management
- Middle management roles easy to create, hard to eliminate as companies age
- Despite ridicule, it's hard, underappreciated but always needed job
- Management as unique skill becoming scarcer due to work-life balance priorities
