AI summary by TwinMind
Why NASA's Next Space Suits are not Pressurized to 14.7psi - Smarter Every Day 296
SmarterEveryDay
1h 17m 28s
Introduction and Context Setting
- NASA conducting technical decision on spacesuit pressure for Artemis program
- Apollo program was "flags and footprints," Artemis designed for permanent lunar presence
- Video filmed at NASA's Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory (NBL) at Johnson Space Center, Houston
- Critical transition from spacecraft to spacesuit affects entire Artemis architecture
Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory Overview
- 40-foot deep swimming pool, largest facility of its kind globally
- Other similar facilities: Star City Moscow, JAXA Japan, small pool in Cologne Germany
- NBL most utilized and heavily used worldwide
- Simulates zero gravity through neutral buoyancy - no preferred orientation
- Supports 6-hour EVA runs end-to-end
- Trains Navy divers, Air Force Pararescue (PJs) for capsule recovery
- Simulates day/night cycles (45 minutes light/45 minutes dark per 90-minute orbit)
Key Personnel Introductions
- Dominic del Rosso: Chief engineer at NBL
- Former zero gravity program manager
- Fire chief, NASA WB-57 Canberra backseater
- Afghanistan volunteer service
- Diving instructor trainer, dive safety board member
- Pat Keller: Master scuba diver trainer
- Trained thousands of divers
- Safety jumper for speed boats
- NBL maintenance department and scuba instructor manager
- Adam: Test conductor (engineer by training, operations team)
- 2.5 months planning for this single test
- Certification run with supervisor Tess evaluating
Scuba Diving Physics and NBL Special Gas Mix
- Normal air: 78% nitrogen, 21% oxygen, trace gases
- Water pressure increases with depth, forcing more nitrogen into bloodstream
- Rapid ascent causes "the bends" (decompression sickness)
- Standard diving uses nitrox (higher oxygen %) for longer bottom time
- NBL uses custom 46% oxygen nitrox blend
- Allows unlimited bottom time at 40-foot depth
- Eliminates decompression concerns for 6-hour astronaut training sessions
- Higher than recreational/industrial mixes
- Prevents oxygen toxicity while maximizing safety
Current ISS EVA Pre-breathe Protocol
- ISS atmospheric pressure: 14.7 psi (similar to Earth)
- EMU spacesuit pressure: 4.3 psi
- Total pre-breathe time: 3.5 hours
- Phase 1: Breathing 100% oxygen (not in suit)
- Phase 2: Depressurize Quest airlock to 10.2 psi
- Phase 3: Don spacesuits, continue pre-breathing
- Alternating 15 minutes rest/15 minutes light exercise
- Prevents decompression sickness from pressure differential
Test Objectives and Pressure Investigation
- Primary goal: Characterize EVA performance at elevated suit pressure
- Test pressure: 6.2 psi (vs standard 4.3 psi)
- Rationale: Reduce pre-breathe time by narrowing pressure differential
- Ideal scenario: Zero pre-breathe (suit pressure = habitat pressure)
- XEMU suit rating: Designed for up to 8.2 psi operation
- Blinded test protocol: Subjects, test conductor, most team unaware of actual pressure
- Possibility of different pressures for different astronauts
Spacesuit Physics and Operation
- Current ISS suit delta pressure: 4.3 psi over ambient
- Suit acts like pressurized balloon - higher pressure = more resistance to movement
- "Don't fight the suit" principle: Use designed joint movements and bearings
- Proper technique: Roll shoulder, extend arm through joints rather than forcing movement
- Glove operation: Fingers have preferred position when pressurized
- Higher pressure increases finger closure difficulty
Lunar Gravity Simulation Challenges
- Moon gravity: 1/6th Earth gravity
- Key physics principle: Weight reduced but mass/inertia unchanged
- Arthur C. Clarke quote: "Six times more sluggish than weight suggests"
- Walking challenges: Must lean further forward to initiate movement
- Center of gravity management critical - mismanagement causes falls
- Apollo astronaut falls: Typically CG management errors
Center of Gravity and Buoyancy Calculations
- Partial Gravity Weigh-Out Stand: Three-point load cell system
- Process:
- Astronaut positioned upright, measured
- Tilted 20 degrees forward, measured again
- Two vectors intersect to determine 3D center of gravity (CG)
- Underwater measurement determines center of buoyancy (CB)
- Goal: Align CG and CB to eliminate riding moments
- Trimming process: Divers adjust weights and foam blocks around astronaut
- Target: 1/6th gravity simulation with stable orientation
Test Execution and Astronaut Performance
- Subjects: Jessica Meir and Randy Bresnik (combined 1+ year space experience)
- Dive support: 8 divers total (4 per astronaut)
- 2 safety divers, 1 utility diver, 1 float diver per subject
- Communication: One-way audio from astronauts to dive team via underwater speakers
- Tasks: Controlled activities (rock collection, tool manipulation, cart pushing)
- Observations:
- Jessica found stable kneeling positions with leg extended
- Randy experienced falls during CG transitions, learned recovery techniques
- Both astronauts problem-solved mobility challenges in real-time
Suit Engineering and Design
- XEMU: NASA government reference design suit
- xEVAS contract: Working with Axiom and Collins for flight suits
- Suit test engineer role: Christine Davis (mechanical engineer, 8 years experience)
- Suit features:
- Valsalva device for ear clearing (foam block to block nostrils)
- Cooling garment with liquid circulation
- Boot and glove tightening systems
- Integrated sensors and communication systems
Astronaut Feedback and Performance Analysis
- Jessica's assessment:
- Much less fatiguing than ISS EVAs
- Could use full body (legs, core) vs. only upper body in microgravity
- Felt like normal pressure (suspected 4.3 psi, not 6.2 psi)
- More natural movement due to gravity orientation
- Randy's assessment:
- Learning CG management crucial
- Problem-solving fall recovery techniques
- Reduced traction in lunar regolith simulant
- Overall: Both found lunar EVA simulation less exhausting than ISS EVAs
Atmospheric Pressure Decision Framework
- Historical context:
- Apollo: ~5 psi oxygen-rich environment, zero pre-breathe
- Skylab: 5 psi oxygen-rich, 22-foot diameter (comparable to 30-foot HLS)
- Trade-offs:
- Lower pressure = reduced pre-breathe time but increased fire hazard
- Higher pressure = better electronics cooling but longer pre-breathe
- Oxygen-rich environments require careful material selection
- Mission considerations:
- Lunar surface: 6 days, four 8-hour EVAs planned
- Pre-breathe time directly impacts available EVA time
- Different mission durations may require different atmospheric strategies
Future Architecture Implications
- Flexibility goal: Adaptable systems for various mission profiles
- Russian approach: Variable suit pressure during EVA (high for transit, low for detailed work)
- Multi-vehicle considerations: Orion, Gateway, HLS pressure standardization questions
- Long-duration missions: Potential physiological effects of reduced pressure atmospheres
