AI summary by TwinMind
Why Price Volatility is NOT Risk
The Plain Bagel
12m 19s
Skillshare Sponsorship
- Video sponsored by Skillshare
- Free 2-month premium trial available via link
- First 1,000 people get unlimited access to courses
Risk vs Return Fundamentals
- Risk = fundamental balancing force of investing
- Yin to return's yang
- Forces consideration of potential losses vs earnings
- Each investor has unique risk tolerance based on circumstances
- Should not exceed personal risk level to avoid financial danger
Traditional Risk Measurement - Volatility
- Conventional answer: volatility = how much stock price fluctuates
- Volatility measures represent risk in formulas, models, theories used globally
- Standard deviation: how much something deviates from average
- Beta: how much stock deviates from market as whole
- Logic: efficient market reflects all company information
- Fluctuating price = investor uncertainty = higher risk
- Higher volatility = more likely to reach lower lows
- Increases chance of selling when down
Warren Buffett's 2007 Challenge
- Famous declaration: "volatility does not measure risk"
- Not universal agreement - many investors/traders believe volatility is best risk measure
- Alternative perspective helps avoid common pitfalls
- Better tolerance of market declines
Three Shortcomings of Volatility
1. Not All Volatility is Bad
- Volatility measures dispersion from mean (includes up and down movements)
- Example: Stock A declining vs Stock B volatile but rising
- According to volatility: Stock B riskier
- According to loss probability: Stock A clearly riskier
- Downside deviation addresses this by only measuring downward movements
2. Backwards Looking Measure
- Requires historical pricing data
- Tells past risk, not future risk (what investors should care about)
- Example: Company with stable utility + experimental potato-powered cars
- Historical volatility stable
- Sells utility business = now higher risk (potato cars only)
- Volatility won't reflect change until time passes
- May still appear appropriate for conservative investors despite reality
3. Focuses on Price, Not Value
- Debate between active vs passive investors
- Value investors: stock prices can deviate from true worth
- Price fluctuation ≠ value change
- Buffett's farmland example:
- Acre selling for $2,000, drops to $600
- Volatility suggests $600 purchase riskier than $2,000
- Reality: same asset at steep discount = less money at risk
- Stocks = one of few things humans prefer buying when expensive
Alternative Risk Definition
- Risk = probability of losing money/permanent capital impairment
- Only two causes of capital impairment:
- Selling when stock price down (losses only realized when selling)
- Irrevocable change to underlying investment
- Company nature/business changes
- Decline in inherent value
- Product obsolescence
- New regulation hampering operations
Practical Application
- Average investor can't stop company failure
- Can control selling decisions
- Holding forever doesn't guarantee profit
- Emotional creatures make poor decisions watching stocks daily
- Controlling impulses + ignoring volatility = reduced probability of selling when down = lower risk
- Farmer perspective: if growing same crops as before, no additional risk despite market price changes
Limitations and Nuances
- Viewpoint benefits individual investors but doesn't provide calculation method
- Volatility still best quantification tool for many
- Author uses standard deviation for risk-adjusted return comparisons
- Volatility has value in certain circumstances
- Primary risk when short-term time horizon (e.g., 30-day selling timeline)
- Long-term investing: volatility doesn't paint whole picture
- May tempt selling when down = increases loss probability
