AI summary by TwinMind

Why Price Volatility is NOT Risk

The Plain Bagel

12m 19s

Skillshare Sponsorship

  • Video sponsored by Skillshare
  • Free 2-month premium trial available via link
  • First 1,000 people get unlimited access to courses

Risk vs Return Fundamentals

  • Risk = fundamental balancing force of investing
  • Yin to return's yang
  • Forces consideration of potential losses vs earnings
  • Each investor has unique risk tolerance based on circumstances
  • Should not exceed personal risk level to avoid financial danger

Traditional Risk Measurement - Volatility

  • Conventional answer: volatility = how much stock price fluctuates
  • Volatility measures represent risk in formulas, models, theories used globally
  • Standard deviation: how much something deviates from average
  • Beta: how much stock deviates from market as whole
  • Logic: efficient market reflects all company information
    • Fluctuating price = investor uncertainty = higher risk
    • Higher volatility = more likely to reach lower lows
    • Increases chance of selling when down

Warren Buffett's 2007 Challenge

  • Famous declaration: "volatility does not measure risk"
  • Not universal agreement - many investors/traders believe volatility is best risk measure
  • Alternative perspective helps avoid common pitfalls
  • Better tolerance of market declines

Three Shortcomings of Volatility

1. Not All Volatility is Bad

  • Volatility measures dispersion from mean (includes up and down movements)
  • Example: Stock A declining vs Stock B volatile but rising
  • According to volatility: Stock B riskier
  • According to loss probability: Stock A clearly riskier
  • Downside deviation addresses this by only measuring downward movements

2. Backwards Looking Measure

  • Requires historical pricing data
  • Tells past risk, not future risk (what investors should care about)
  • Example: Company with stable utility + experimental potato-powered cars
    • Historical volatility stable
    • Sells utility business = now higher risk (potato cars only)
    • Volatility won't reflect change until time passes
    • May still appear appropriate for conservative investors despite reality

3. Focuses on Price, Not Value

  • Debate between active vs passive investors
  • Value investors: stock prices can deviate from true worth
  • Price fluctuation ≠ value change
  • Buffett's farmland example:
    • Acre selling for $2,000, drops to $600
    • Volatility suggests $600 purchase riskier than $2,000
    • Reality: same asset at steep discount = less money at risk
    • Stocks = one of few things humans prefer buying when expensive

Alternative Risk Definition

  • Risk = probability of losing money/permanent capital impairment
  • Only two causes of capital impairment:
    1. Selling when stock price down (losses only realized when selling)
    2. Irrevocable change to underlying investment
      • Company nature/business changes
      • Decline in inherent value
      • Product obsolescence
      • New regulation hampering operations

Practical Application

  • Average investor can't stop company failure
  • Can control selling decisions
  • Holding forever doesn't guarantee profit
  • Emotional creatures make poor decisions watching stocks daily
  • Controlling impulses + ignoring volatility = reduced probability of selling when down = lower risk
  • Farmer perspective: if growing same crops as before, no additional risk despite market price changes

Limitations and Nuances

  • Viewpoint benefits individual investors but doesn't provide calculation method
  • Volatility still best quantification tool for many
  • Author uses standard deviation for risk-adjusted return comparisons
  • Volatility has value in certain circumstances
  • Primary risk when short-term time horizon (e.g., 30-day selling timeline)
  • Long-term investing: volatility doesn't paint whole picture
  • May tempt selling when down = increases loss probability

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome