AI summary by TwinMind
Why Russia and North Korea Partnership is WORST Case Scenario
The Infographics Show
13m 32s
Historical Context: Russia-North Korea Relations
- Putin's last visit to North Korea was during first year in office when Kim Jong-il ruled
- Kim Jong-un was under fake name in Swiss boarding school at the time
- Previous visit was diplomatic trip to reassert Russian power over Cold War sphere of influence
- Russian Federation post-USSR was significantly weaker and more closely aligned with West
- Russia once considered joining NATO, but Germany and European nations balked
- Concerns it was ruse for Putin to pull NATO apart from within
Early 2000s US-Russia Cooperation
- US and Russia normalizing relations at steady pace
- After 9/11 2001, Putin first to call President Bush offering condolences
- Russia agreed to intelligence sharing program
- Based FBI personnel in Russia during war on terror
- Putin allowed American supplies flow through Russian territory into Afghanistan
- Iraq invasion significantly soured US-Russian relationship
- Russia believed US seeking undue influence in Middle East
- Despite souring relations, Russia-North Korea relationship remained unchanged
- Russia signed on to most punishing sanctions against North Korea
Putin's 2024 Visit Details
- Kim Jong-un met Putin at 3:00 AM local time in Pyongyang when plane touched down
- Visit was desperation for Putin, opportunism for Kim
- Both sides stand to gain great deal, world stands to lose just as much
North Korean Military Aid to Russia
- Since Ukraine invasion start, North Korea shipped estimated 10,000 rail cargo containers of weapons to Russia
- Aid mostly artillery shells and ballistic missiles
- Some replacement artillery tubes and other odds and ends
- North Korea operates old Soviet equipment, easy to resupply Russia
- Russia fires 10,000 shells per day
- Russia only produces about 250,000 shells per month
- Significant shortfall forces Russia to conserve ammunition
- Opens opportunities for Ukrainian counterattacks
- Reduced effectiveness of Russian offensives (Kharkiv region example: 2 weeks, only meager tracks of land gained)
- Ukrainian reports: Russia's artillery assault steadily slowing over last year
- New North Korea deal threatens to return Russian 10:1 fire superiority
North Korean Production Capabilities
- South Korean defense minister Shin Won-sik estimates:
- North sent over 3 million 152mm shells
- Can produce around 2 million shells per year
- North Korea factories only operating at 30% capacity due to material shortages and electricity issues
- Some factories operating at full capacity to supply Russia
- Fear: Russia might send enough raw materials and fuel to fully power North Korea's manufacturing capability
- Would allow North to produce shells well out of reach of Ukrainian weapons
Quality Issues with North Korean Weapons
- North Korean shells notoriously lower quality than Russian-produced
- Reports from front: inconsistent power loads resulting in decreased accuracy
- Manufacturing standards supposed to result in uniform power load for predictable trajectory
- North Korean standards far from uniform, uneven loads decrease accuracy
- Reports of 30% failure rate from North Korean shells and rockets
- Catastrophic failures leading to loss of gun barrels or lives
- Reports difficult to verify (anecdotal from Russian military bloggers)
- Russian military not forthcoming with official reports
2010 Yeonpyeong Island Attack Case Study
- November 23, 2010: North-South tensions flared to catastrophic levels
- North revealed new uranium enrichment facility
- US considering military action, South Korea mulling US nukes on territory
- South Korea running annual Hoguk exercise with US partners
- North contacted South warning against live ammunition firing into waters around Baengnyeong and Yeonpyeong Islands
- South ignored warning, proceeded with live fire exercises at 2:34 PM local time
- North Korean artillery from Mudo island and Kaemori mainland opened fire on Yeonpyeong Island
- Attack waves: 2:34-2:55 PM and 3:10-3:41 PM
- Approximately 108 shells fired at South, striking military camp and nearby village
- South returned fire: 80 shells from K9 Thunder 155mm guns (two damaged, third blocked by dud)
- South Korean casualties: 2 Marines killed, 2 civilians killed, 6 military seriously injured, 10 minor wounds
- Fires destroyed 21 homes and warehouses, most forests and fields on island
- US satellite reconnaissance: South largely ineffective in response
- Key finding: estimated half of North Korean munitions failed to hit island, quarter failed to detonate
- Poor quality control, manufacturing standards, storage conditions to blame
Current War Performance Comparison
- At Ukraine war start: 50% of Russian missiles failed to detonate or missed targets
- Dud rate well above <1% considered acceptable by US military
- When you have enough weapons, can mitigate poor quality effects
Russia's Compensation to North Korea
- Russia to provide increased fuel and raw materials to impoverished North
- Russia (most sanctioned nation in history) has large stockpile with few buyers
China's Concerns
- China prided itself as keeper of North Korea "on leash" since USSR fall
- China is North's largest trading partner, delivers most fuel and raw materials
- China accounts for over 90% of North's total imports and exports
- Relationship advantageous to Beijing despite drawbacks:
- Keeps US off-balance
- Acts as destabilizing force in Korean Peninsula
- Limits America's ability to respond to Chinese aggression in South China Sea
- Prevents South Korea from fully committing to supporting US against China
- Russia threatening this relationship
- Kim Jong-un happy to switch masters or decrease reliance on China
- Kim chafed at Beijing's control over his ambitions
- Russian relations could give breathing room to assert independence
- Strains Chinese-Russian relationship
- Chinese foreign minister read prepared statement during Putin visit: neutral tone hints at consternation
- Russia may be repaying favor: China invited Kazakhstan and former Soviet republics to economic conference without inviting Russia
- Chinese investments in region steadily outpacing Russian ones
Putin's Vietnam Visit
- North Korea was one stop on Putin's Asia tour, continued to Vietnam
- Russia historical provider of Vietnamese arms until recently
- Vietnam began looking toward West and US
- Vietnam seeking to avoid Cold War repeat (forced to choose sides)
- Putin made real reason for North Korea visit known in Vietnam
South Korea's Role and Putin's Warning
- South Korea supplying Ukraine with non-lethal aid since conflict start
- As war intensifies and North Korean shipments revealed, South Korea increasingly considering lethal aid
- Putin and Russians fear South Korean lethal aid
- South Korean weapons considered exceptional quality compared to North Korean counterparts
- Putin announced considering providing North Korea military equipment if South sends arms to Ukraine
- Sent alarm bells from Seoul to Washington
Potential Russian Military Aid to North Korea
- Influx of Russian arms could destabilize peninsula
- Increase North's military capabilities by order of magnitude (given largely obsolete/antique army)
- Fears aid could include consulting on long-range ballistic missile design for nuclear weapons delivery
- Moscow believed to have already helped North with space program
- Last year: Pyongyang launched first spy satellite coinciding with warming Russia relations
- Expected North Korea satellite capabilities will grow with Russian aid
Mutual Defense Pact
- Putin signed mutual defense pact in Pyongyang
- Extent purposefully ambiguous
- Similar pact signed by USSR-North Korea after Korean War
- Quote: "immediately come to each other's aid with all means available"
- Ambiguous wording doesn't represent actual defense commitment
- Purposeful ambiguity serves to:
- Keep South Korea and allies guessing about provocation levels
- Allow Russia to not truly commit to disastrous defense of North in case of war
Strategic Implications
- Putin's visit both stern warning to South Korea and attempt to flex international muscles
- Regain credibility lost after Ukraine invasion
- If South Korea sends lethal aid to Ukraine, risks Russia increasing cooperation with North
- Probable transfer of military technology
- Puts pressure on US as Russia helps North's ability to strike continental US with nuclear weapons
- Putin's visit may be defiance toward China (officially senior partner, fact Russians deeply resent)
