Summary by TwinMind · 5m 1s
Summary by TwinMind · 5m 1s

Why Shakespeare Could Never Have Been French

Why Shakespeare Could Never Have Been French

Tom Scott

Tom Scott

Location and Context

  • Filming on location in Stratford-Upon-Avon (Shakespeare's birthplace)
  • Temperature ~2°C above freezing
  • Presenter dealing with aggressive swans
  • First time taking "Language Files" on location vs studio green-screen

Shakespeare's Background

  • Born 1564 in Stratford-Upon-Avon
  • Plays/poetry have distinctive rhythm and feeling
  • French-speaking poet couldn't write something sounding like Shakespeare
  • Language affects possible poetry/verse writing

English Lexical Stress

  • English has lexical stress (stress built into words)
  • Examples: "CON-test" (noun) vs "con-TEST" (verb)
  • Wrong stress placement sounds ridiculous: "syl-LAB-le" vs "SYL-la-ble"
  • Stressed syllables integral to English speech/poetic writing

Prosodic Stress vs Lexical Stress

  • Prosodic stress: emphasis for meaning
    • "I want that" vs "I want that" vs "I want that"
    • All different interpretations of same three words
  • Focus on lexical stress (built into words) not prosodic stress
  • Lexical stress crucial in English poetry where meter/timing matter

Limerick Example

  • Demonstrates lexical stress importance in English poetry
  • "There once was a man from..." works with:
    • Leeds (one syllable)
    • Madras (stress on correct beat)
  • Doesn't work with Washington:
    • "There once was a man from Washington" - stress too early
    • "There once was a man from Wa-SHING-ton" - forced stress sounds wrong
  • Solution: "There once was a man... from Washington" (with pause, but clunky)
  • Rule: lexical stress must land on the beat

French Language Stress Patterns

  • French lacks lexical stress
  • French speakers use prosodic stress for emphasis
  • Default stress lands on last syllable of utterance
  • To sound French: emphasize only last syllable of phrases
  • Cannot create limericks in French due to lack of lexical stress

Shakespeare's Iambic Pentameter

  • "Iambic pentameter" = stress every other syllable in pairs
  • Five pairs per line
  • Shakespeare's usual style (with exceptions)
  • Example: "If MU-sic BE the FOOD of LOVE, play ON"
  • Creates Shakespeare's distinctive rhythm

Translation Challenges

  • French cannot replicate iambic pentameter
  • French stress sits at end of utterance
  • Can translate words/sentences/meanings but not sound
  • Poetry translation often doesn't sound right/poetic
  • Must translate style and stress patterns, not just words

French Alternative: Alexandrine

  • French equivalent poetic form
  • 12 syllables per line, broken into two parts
  • Should rhyme
  • Stress end of each half
  • English has alexandrine form but works differently than French original

Conclusion

  • French poets can have Shakespeare's wordplay/drama skills
  • But could never sound like Shakespeare due to language constraints
  • Reference to Gretchen McCulloch's Lingthusiasm podcast for more translation content