AI summary by TwinMind
Why some "remastered" music videos look awful
Tom Scott
7m 52s
YouTube Music Video Remastering Background (2019)
- YouTube remastered early platform music videos in 2019
- Music labels maintained same video IDs, views, comments
- Old videos suddenly available in HD with varying quality results
High-Quality Remastering Examples
- Last Christmas: Now in 4K, looks spectacular
- Shot on film at full cinema quality
- Can be projected on building side
- Freddie Mercury's "Living on My Own": Stunning remaster
- Kept original aspect ratio from 80s television
- Didn't convert to widescreen
Technical Process: Film to Video Conversion
- Music videos originally meant for television, not cinema
- Film processed through telecine (TV camera pointed at film projector)
- Results saved to videotape
- Quality crushed to standard definition: 480 horizontal lines (US), 576 (Europe)
- Videotape editing cheaper/easier than physical film editing
- Most music videos finalized on videotape format
Premium Remastering Process
- Last Christmas remaster: Engineers tracked down original film reels
- Rescanned using modern 4K technology
- Recreated every edit frame-for-frame, cut-for-cut
- Only found 7 of 8 original reels
- Few shots sourced from TV-quality version (visible quality difference)
Budget Remastering Alternative
- Take final TV edit from cleanest professional videotape
- Upscale to HD without recreating from scratch
- Less sharp than original film but better than previous versions
- Bohemian Rhapsody used this method
Bohemian Rhapsody Remastering Issues
- Over 1 billion YouTube views, iconic status
- Not shot on film - recorded on TV cameras, edited on videotape
- Effects required live feedback to camera (TV camera pointed at monitor)
- Never existed in high-quality film version
- Originally standard definition only
Technical Specifications: European TV Standards
- European analog TV: 50 frames/second (60 in US)
- Interlacing: half horizontal lines skipped each time
- Reduces flickering on old equipment
- Authentic 70s experience: standard definition, 50 interlaced frames/second
Deinterlacing Process
- YouTube version: computer-generated HD at 25 frames/second
- Algorithm fills gaps, smooths jagged edges
- Creates film-like picture from limited data
- Remastering = recreation, not restoration
- Changes historical record despite "as meant to be seen" marketing
Smash Mouth "All Star" Disaster
- Extremely poor remaster quality
- Face appears as "demon child" - wrongly scaled, over-sharpened
- Diagonal lines jagged and stepped
- Badly deinterlaced with ghosting artifacts
- Cheerleader appears in two places simultaneously in same frame
- Mixed frame rates: some 60fps TV camera, some 30fps film, some 24fps (Mystery Men tie-in)
- Aspect ratio incorrectly squeezed
- HD remaster worse than original version
Production Issues Analysis
- Likely underpaid/overworked VFX technician
- Given low-quality, broken source material
- "Just Smash Mouth, we don't care" attitude
- Basic resizer used, sharpness maximally increased
- Complete technical mess across multiple parameters
