AI summary by TwinMind
Why the Bank of Japan Bought $300 Billion of Stocks
Asianometry
19m 38s
Introduction and Context (December 2020)
- Bank of Japan became single biggest shareholder of Japanese stocks
- Bought hundreds of billions of dollars of Tokyo-listed stock ETFs over decade
- Sitting on $130 billion profit from stock purchases
- Unprecedented central bank strategy - never done before in this way
Historical Background: Plaza Accord and Lost Decade
- 1985 Plaza Accord signed by Japan and 4 other countries
- Depreciated USD against Japanese yen and German deutsche mark
- Dollar lost 51% of value against yen over 2 years
- Japan entered to avoid tariffs on goods in American market
- Yen appreciation plunged Japanese manufacturing into recession
- Bank of Japan loosened monetary policy, lowered interest rates
- Cheap money went into stocks, real estate, asset speculation instead of productive investments
- Peak bubble prices: Tokyo Imperial Palace valued more than all California property
- Japanese bought Pebble Beach golf club for $850 million
- Bubble popped early 1990s when BoJ tightened lending regulations
- Banks left with over 90 trillion yen worth of non-performing loans
- Lost decade: 1991-2010, average real growth barely above 1%
- Government racked up debt trying to stimulate economy with little effect
- 1998: Bank of Japan received formal independence from government
Early Quantitative Easing (2000s)
- Bank of Japan began quantitative easing in 2000s
- Directly purchased Japanese bonds of various maturities
- Targeted zero interest rate policy
- Effects studied but no general conclusion on effectiveness
- QE lowered lending costs for banks, spurred more lending to riskier borrowers
- 2010: BoJ expanded QE to include corporate bonds and longer duration assets
- First time began buying corporate stocks and REITs as part of QE program
Central Bank Stock Purchase Rationale
- Goal: stimulate risk-taking among people and firms
- Only 10% of Japanese people held stocks vs 36% in US, 18% in eurozone
- Majority of Japanese owned cash and bonds
- Wealth effect theory: rising stock values → feel richer → spend more
- Corporate side: make capital raising cheaper → spur investment
- Japanese companies famously conservative
Historical Precedents for Central Bank Stock Purchases
- Bank of Japan bought stocks from failing banks in 2002 and 2009 (financial stability)
- Hong Kong Monetary Authority bought $17 billion worth of stocks/bonds during 1998 Asian financial crisis
- Sold after crisis, doubled investment
- These precedents modest compared to Japan's upcoming program
- No bank ever bought stocks in volume to stimulate economy
Initial Program Implementation (2010-2012)
- First plan: 450 billion yen ($4.5 billion USD) stock purchases, end December 2011
- Tokyo Stock Exchange total market cap: $5.7 trillion USD at time
- Through 2011-2012: increased cap fourfold to 2.5 trillion yen ($19 billion)
- Japanese government bond yields fell but yen continued appreciating
- Reached exchange rate of 80 yen to dollar despite currency interventions
- Stronger yen counterbalanced loose monetary effects
- Made Japanese exports more expensive, hurt manufacturers
- Mild deflation continued, 2% inflation target seemed unreachable
Abenomics Era (2012-2013)
- December 2012: Shinzo Abe won election as Prime Minister
- Campaign promises: $120 billion emergency stimulus spending
- Force BoJ to perform unprecedented monetary moves
- Yen quickly deflated: 84 yen/dollar (Dec 2012) to 95 yen/dollar (March 2013)
- Stock prices rose in anticipation
- April 2013: Abe appointed Haruhiko Kuroda as BoJ governor
- Kuroda tasked with monetary aspects of "Abenomics"
Quantitative and Qualitative Monetary Easing (QQE)
- QQE policy announced: "go where no bank has gone before"
- Goal: reduce price of risk across all assets
- Expand monetary base by 60-70 trillion yen annually ($540-630 billion USD)
- Early promise: inflation spiked 2013-2014
- 2014 disruption: consumption tax raised from 5% to 8%
- BoJ response: bought more bonds, tripled ETF buying
- Abe delayed second tax hike
Market Distortions and Targeting Changes
- 4 years into policy: purchases warping stock market
- Diversified from Nikkei 225 to include:
- Nikkei 400
- TOPIX
- ETFs tracking companies making "investments in physical and human capital"
- Examples: Nomura Enterprise Value Allocation Index, Daiwa MSCI Japan Human and Physical Investment ETF
- Companies included: Toyota, Nintendo, Tokyo Electron, Fanuc
Pre-Pandemic Holdings (2020)
- BoJ held 40 trillion yen ($360 billion) of stocks on balance sheet
- Holdings accounted for over 5% of country's entire stock market
- For 1 out of every 2 Tokyo-listed companies, BoJ was top 10 shareholder
- Was Fanuc's biggest shareholder
Pandemic Response (2020-2021)
- Raised ETF purchase ceiling to 12 trillion yen ($112 billion USD)
- Actually bought only 7.1 trillion yen ($64 billion) in 2020
- March 2021: purchased 300 billion yen ($2.7 billion) worth of ETFs
- Program slowing down but not formally ended
Policy Effectiveness Analysis
- Inflation 2011-2019: more inflation than deflation during 10-year period
- Real GDP growth: Japanese economy grew (excluding pandemic years)
- ETF purchases correlated with Nikkei 225 returns
- Stock prices rose, some Japanese stockholders got richer
- Challenging global conditions in US and eurozone during 2010s
- Consumption tax hike in 2014 could have caused permanent damage
- Argument: without BoJ actions, things could have been much worse
Five Major Problems with Stock Buying Program
1. Corporate Governance Issues
- Japanese companies lack transparency on business operations
- Shareholders have few ways to replace poor management
- Management compensation less tied to performance
- BoJ doesn't exercise voting rights despite being biggest stockholder
- Risk of government involvement in private companies (similar to China criticism)
2. Price Discovery Problems
- ETF growth risks freezing relative valuations of biggest companies
- More ETFs created → more biggest stocks bought simply because they're big
- Example: Fast Retailing (Uniqlo) overrepresented on Nikkei 225 vs TOPIX
- 11% weight in Nikkei 225
- $18 billion revenue company became $80 billion giant
- Founder Tadashi Yanai became Japan's richest man ($40 billion fortune)
- Lost 6% value when BoJ announced phasing out Nikkei 225 ETF purchases
3. Exit Strategy Uncertainty
- What will BoJ do with all its stocks?
- If they sell, will they crash the market?
- Anticipation of future sales dampens current buying effects
- Wealth gains only on paper
- No announced plans for ETF holdings
4. Limited Economic Impact
- Studies up to 2019: publicly listed companies didn't spend more on R&D or grow sales
- Price-to-earnings ratio actually declined despite higher stock prices
- Market more out of favor in 2019 than 2011
- 2020-2021 jump likely due to worldwide stimulus, not BoJ purchases
- Companies sold shares but kept cash on books instead of investing
5. Wage Stagnation
- Japanese workers make less than 30 years ago
- Monetary easing likely worsens wage stagnation
- Focus on companies neglects impact on people
Global Implications and Future Outlook
- BoJ actions foretell what other central banks might do
- Timeline: BoJ QE (early 2000s) → Fed QE (2008) → Fed corporate bond ETF purchases (May 2020)
- May 2020: Federal Reserve started buying corporate bond ETFs (first time ever)
- Corporate bonds not far from stocks
- Japanese vs American economies very different
- Japan's stock buying had limited, short-lasting effect on economic prospects
- USA should consider Japan's experience for future policy decisions
