AI summary by TwinMind
Why There Are No Flights Between India and China
PolyMatter
19m 30s
Historical Context and Current Situation
- China Eastern Flight 564 last direct flight between India-China on March 20, 2020
- Delhi to Shanghai route: 5 hours 24 minutes
- 200 passengers on Airbus A330
- As of September 6th: 1,631 days without direct commercial flights (4.5 years)
- Geographic isolation unprecedented for two most populous nations
- India: 1.417 billion people
- China: 1.412 billion people
- Together: one-third of humanity
- Pre-pandemic: 539 flights in December 2019
Regional Flight Connectivity Analysis
- Within 3,000-mile radius of Beijing: 32 countries/territories
- 29 have direct flights to China including Afghanistan, Brunei, Taiwan, North Korea
- Only 3 exceptions: Palau (18,000 people), Bhutan (no traffic lights), India
- Geographic barriers make land travel impossible
- Lhasa-Sikkim: 200 miles direct, 4,000-mile detour by car (120 hours)
- Tibetan Plateau: 20,000+ foot mountains
- Current fastest journey: twice as long with Hong Kong layover
Border Dispute Background
- World's longest disputed border split into 3 sections
- Eastern Section:
- 1914 agreement between British India, Republic of China, Tibet
- Tibet-British India agreed on border line
- China never recognized Tibet's sovereignty to sign agreement
- China calls current Indian-controlled area "South Tibet"
- Middle Section:
- 34-square-mile area claimed by China, overlaps with Bhutan claims
- Strategic importance: proximity to Siliguri Corridor ("Chicken's Neck")
- Corridor only 14 miles wide at shortest point
- Western Section:
- India claims Aksai Chin (15,000 square miles, twice New Jersey size)
- Currently controlled by China
- Strategically vital: connects Xinjiang and Tibet provinces
- Enables rapid Chinese border reinforcement
Line of Actual Control (LAC) Issues
- Informal boundary placeholder, mutually disliked
- No demilitarized buffer zone unlike Korean DMZ
- Overlapping interpretations of LAC location
- "Use it or lose it" mentality requires active patrolling
- Virtually guarantees conflict between nuclear powers
June 2020 Galwan Valley Incident
- June 15th: Indian soldiers entered disputed Galwan Valley area
- Mission: verify Chinese withdrawal as previously agreed
- Discovered and began destroying Chinese-built structure
- Fighting broke out using primitive weapons (rocks, sticks, clubs)
- 1996 agreement prohibited guns/explosives
- First deadly encounter in 45 years
- Casualties: 20 Indian soldiers, 35-43 Chinese soldiers suspected killed
- Both sides blame other for provocation
- India: China built aggressively in new territory
- China: reaction to Indian construction on Chinese side
Economic Retaliation and Visa Restrictions
- India imports $120 billion annually from China (largest trading partner)
- China imports only 15% as much from India
- Indian countermeasures:
- Banned hundreds of Chinese apps including TikTok
- New rules/restrictions on Chinese companies
- Banned Huawei from networks
- Investigating Chinese firms for tax violations
- Visa restrictions:
- Chinese citizens cannot apply online for Indian visas
- Must apply in China even if living abroad
- Requirements only revealed after application
- Requirements frequently change
- Nearly all applications rejected
- 2,000 visas granted in 2024 vs 200,000 in 2019
- Zero journalists from either country in the other
Strategic Military Developments
- Post-2020: China fortified border with new bridges/structures
- Capability to house up to 120,000 soldiers in Aksai Chin
- China gained strategic military advantage
- Diplomatic positions:
- Beijing: resume flights first, then discuss border
- New Delhi: discuss border first, then resume flights
Economic Trajectory Shifts
- China's decline:
- Slower economic growth, reduced consumer spending
- Flights to US/Canada down 63%, France 57%, Taiwan 70%
- Russian airspace ban extends flight times (Beijing-London: 10→13 hours)
- Beijing Capital Airport: 2nd busiest (2019) → 23rd busiest (2023)
- India's boom:
- Indira Gandhi Airport: 16th (2019) → 10th (2023)
- Airports doubled since 2014: 74 → 148
- Major rail/road infrastructure investment
- Population surpassed China's in 2022 (China now shrinking)
- Airline ordered 500 Airbus A320s (largest commercial aviation purchase)
- Only 3% of population has flown (untapped growth potential)
Current Stalemate
- Beijing: newfound urgency to restore economic ties
- New Delhi: no hurry, using relationship as leverage
- Half-decade stalemate continues
- Future conflict likely when troops meet again at border
- Warning shots fired post-June 2020 (violating previous agreements)
- Erosion of peacekeeping rules/restraints increases conflict vulnerability
