AI summary by TwinMind

Why This Nobel Prize Winner Thinks Quantum Mechanics is Nonsense

Sabine Hossenfelder

15m 18s

Gerard 't Hooft's Background and Motivation

  • Nobel Prize winner 1999, recent Breakthrough Prize recipient for standard model work
  • Believes quantum mechanics is "nonsense" - has alternative theory
  • Theory largely ignored by physics community
  • Predicts limits for quantum computer capabilities
  • Book: "The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics"
  • Goal: "new approach towards guessing what the theory of the world is"

Standard Quantum Mechanics Overview

  • Objects lack definite properties in quantum mechanics
  • Everything described by wave function (Ψ)
  • Wave function gives probabilities, not exact positions/states
  • Example: 50% probability left side, 50% right side of screen
  • Measurement collapses wave function instantaneously
  • Collapse is non-local - happens everywhere faster than light speed
  • Einstein's objection: violates speed of light limit

't Hooft's Proposed Solution

  • Eliminate wave function collapse entirely
  • Remove free will to make quantum mechanics fully deterministic
  • Current quantum mechanics only gives probabilities
  • 't Hooft's version: results are determined but unpredictable due to lack of information
  • Randomness same origin as classical randomness (dice throw example)
  • Aligns with Einstein's view: "God does not play dice"

Free Will and Bell's Theorem Connection

  • Philosophers debate determinism vs. free will for millennia
  • Quantum indeterminism doesn't provide free will either
  • Bell's theorem (2022 Nobel Prize) assumes experimenter free choice
  • Bell's inequality: deterministic local theories must obey correlation limits
  • Experiments violate inequality → most physicists reject local determinism
  • 't Hooft: problem is Bell's theorem assumptions, specifically "free choice"

Superdeterminism Concept

  • In fully deterministic theory, experimenter choices also predetermined
  • Everything encoded in Big Bang initial conditions
  • Measurement outcomes always fit measurement settings
  • 't Hooft quote: "experimental actions are determined by laws of physics"
  • Key point: experiment and measured system must be correlated
  • Correlations present in universe's initial state
  • Not causation - laws of nature ensure things "fit together"
  • "Mysterious correlation but not at odds with physics laws"

Ontological vs. Standard Wave Functions

  • Standard wave function: useful but not real
  • Ontological wave function: real, gives 100% probability for specific results
  • Classical states (dead cat, live cat) are ontological/real
  • Superposition states (dead AND alive cat) not real in 't Hooft's framework
  • Current quantum mechanics not wrong - just misinterpreted
  • Wave function describes probabilities due to lack of information

Cellular Automaton Theory

  • Deterministic basis behind quantum physics
  • Cellular automata: compact objects proceeding in discrete time steps
  • Interact only with neighbors (nearest neighbor interaction)
  • Ensures locality - no faster-than-light interactions
  • Quantum versions of "gears"
  • Universe made of extremely tiny versions at Planck scale
  • Pixel size: ~1 Planck length (10^-33 cm)
  • Combine to create particles and space itself

Quantum Computing Implications

  • Quantum computers will "run out of steam"
  • Must work with ontological states in cellular automaton
  • Fewer real states than physicists currently believe
  • Prediction: "Factoring numbers with millions of digits into prime factors will not be possible"
  • If large-scale quantum computers succeed, theory is falsified

Critical Analysis

  • Two separate ideas mixed together:
    • Ontological states and local deterministic theory
    • Cellular automaton implementation
  • Cellular automaton problems:
    • Discrete space/time violates Einstein's theory symmetries
    • Difficult to reconcile with existing data
    • Steven Wolfram uses hypergraphs to avoid this issue
  • Ontological states concept:
    • Theoretically possible but lacks practical utility
    • No explanation of what ontological states are
    • No method to determine them
    • Cannot make predictions without this information
  • Interesting fresh perspective on old problem
  • Sad story: ideas ignored despite 't Hooft's credentials

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome