AI summary by TwinMind
Why Toyota is so Behind in Producing Electric Cars
Newsthink
6m 39s
Toyota's Historical Success and Current Challenges
- Former industry leader: overtook GM to become world's largest automaker
- Introduced small compact cars to America beginning 1950s when GM saw no market
- Research firms rated Toyota and Lexus among top automotive brands for years
- Pandemic struggles: chip shortages led to 40% fewer cars/trucks produced fall 2021
- Supply chain issues compounded existing problems
Electric Vehicle Development Delays
- No pure battery-electric vehicle currently on road
- bZ4X in pipeline, revealed fall 2021 but not yet released
- Lagging despite promising clean energy plans two decades ago
- Slow progress contrasts with early hybrid leadership
Early Clean Energy Leadership (1997-2014)
- 1997: Launched first commercial hybrid Prius, "wowed the world"
- Hybrids combine gas engines with electric motors for reduced fuel consumption
- 2012: Produced electric RAV4 - world's only all-electric SUV at time
- Partnership with Tesla for RAV4 EV production
- Shared factory with Tesla temporarily
- Akio Toyoda impressed by Tesla Roadster: "felt the wind of the future"
Toyota-Tesla Partnership Breakdown
- RAV4 EV discontinued after only 2 years (2012-2014)
- Limited customer base: sold only in California
- Issues: long charging times
- Companies parted ways 2014, became rivals
- Toyoda criticized Musk 2 years ago: Tesla has "recipe but lacks kitchen and chef"
Contrasting EV Strategies
Tesla Strategy
- Focused solely on Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs)
- Pure electric, battery-powered vehicles only
Toyota Strategy
- Three non-purely electric vehicle types:
- Hybrids
- Plug-in hybrids (can be plugged in to extend range)
- Hydrogen fuel-cell cars
- Musk dismissed hydrogen as "fool-cell" vehicles
- Fuel cells use hydrogen gas mixing with oxygen to produce electricity
- Musk: difficult to make and store hydrogen in cars
Current Toyota Electrified Vehicle Portfolio
- One hydrogen model: Mirai
- Focus on hybrids and plug-in hybrids
- 500,000 electrified vehicle sales North America 2021 (basically all hybrids/plug-in hybrids)
- Prius Prime: only 25 miles (40 km) EV-only range
- Hybrids seen as stepping stone for consumers not ready for pure electric
Market Trends Favoring Pure Electric
- Battery electric vehicles outselling plug-in hybrids (International Energy Agency data)
- Data compiled before current high gas prices
- Future appears to be all-electric
Toyota's Resistance to Battery-Electric Focus
Akio Toyoda's 2020 Arguments
- Too early to focus solely on battery-powered EVs
- Response to Japan's push to ban gas-powered cars
- Japan would run out of electricity in summer if all cars electric
- Infrastructure upgrades would cost hundreds of billions
Infrastructure Investment Reality
- 100% EV fleet requires billions in grid investment
- Study estimates up to $125 billion for U.S.
- Shuli Goodman (Linux Foundation LF Energy): future grid "more like Internet" with distributed power generation "like a forest"
- EV advocates push renewable energy charging and night charging when demand lower
Employment Concerns
- Going all-in on EVs could cost millions of jobs in Japan
- BEVs have fewer parts, require fewer laborers
- Would shrink third-party supplier ecosystem
Toyota's 2030 EV Plans
- 30 all-electric models by 2030
- 8 million total electrified vehicles target by 2030
- Only 3.5 million will be purely electric
- Still maintaining hybrid focus
- Tesla target: 20 million annually by 2030
Competitive Performance Analysis
bZ4X vs Tesla Comparison
- Less impressive specs than Tesla models
- Lower range than Tesla
- Slower 0-60 mph acceleration than any Tesla model
- Price unknown - could be significantly less than Tesla
Industry Comparison and Future Outlook
- Tesla compared to Apple of cars
- Nokia, Ericsson, Motorola missed smartphone revolution, never caught up to Apple
- Toyota risks same fate if remains reluctant on battery-powered EVs
- EV sales increasing annually
