AI summary by TwinMind
Why Trains are so Expensive
Wendover Productions
12m 39s
Introduction & Comparative Pricing
- Train costs comparable to airfare on major routes
- NY-Washington: $49 train vs $52 plane
- Edinburgh-London: $30 train vs $30 plane
- Paris-Lyon: $30 train vs $53 plane
- Longer routes show greater disparity
- NY-Chicago: $59 plane vs $108 train
- Trains subsidized/government-run vs profitable commercial airlines
- Aircraft cost $49M vs trains cost max $10M total
- Planes burn 1.7 gallons fuel/mile vs trains use clean electric power
Amtrak Cost Breakdown (DC-NY Route)
- Average ticket price: $73 (starts at $49)
- Total operating cost: $50.14 per ticket
- Profit margin: $22.86 per ticket
Staffing Costs ($25.80 per ticket - largest expense)
- 85,000 daily passengers served by 20,000 employees
- Ratio: 1 employee per 4 passengers
- Highly specialized unionized workers
- Average salary: $75,000 (total cost $115,000 including benefits)
- Speed disadvantage: 3.5 hours train vs 1 hour flight work time
- Long-haul routes worse: Chicago-LA 44 hours train vs 4 hours flight
Infrastructure & Equipment Costs
- Train equipment: $9.67 per ticket
- Locomotive: $6.5M
- Each passenger car: $400,000
- 6-car train total: $9.4M
- Track infrastructure: $3.66 per ticket
- Amtrak owns 730 miles of 21,000 miles used
- Pays fees for 20,000 miles of rented track
- Track construction: $1M+ per mile
- Administrative costs: $2.15 per ticket
- Advertising: $1.31 per ticket
Safety & Insurance Costs
- Accident settlements: $0.79 per ticket
- Trains 3x more dangerous than planes but safer than cars
Other Costs
- Miscellaneous expenses: $5.90 per ticket
Profitability Analysis
- Northeast Regional: 8 cents profit per passenger mile
- Acela Express: 29 cents profit per passenger mile
- Profitable routes subsidize unprofitable ones
- Sunset Limited (New Orleans-LA): loses 21.7 cents per passenger mile
- 2,000-mile routes create substantial losses
Dynamic Pricing Strategy
UK Example (Edinburgh-London)
- Three ticket types with 12 variations total:
- Advance: £30-140 (limited quantity, specific train)
- Off-peak: £137 (arrives after 11:17 AM or weekends)
- Anytime: £148 (complete flexibility)
- First-class equivalents available
- Rail cards provide 1/3 discount for young/disabled/elderly
- Same journey: one passenger pays £20, adjacent pays £200
Pricing Philosophy
- Operators want maximum revenue per passenger
- Subliminally determine willingness to pay
- Early buyers (tourists) get cheaper advance fares
- Business travelers pay premium for flexibility
- Roughly same cost for 5 vs 500 passengers
Rural Service Obligations
Profitable vs Unprofitable Routes
- If only profitable routes operated, map would be minimal
- Amtrak serves 500+ destinations in 46 states
- Many small towns have no other public transport options
Economic Impact Examples
- Havre, Montana to Chicago: cheaper by train than plane
- Chicago-London flight cheaper than Havre-Chicago flight
- Average Havre resident income: $22,000/year
- Rural airports extremely expensive to operate (runway, terminal, security, ATC)
- Rural train stations need minimal infrastructure
Social Mobility Research
- Transport access stronger predictor of upward mobility than:
- Crime levels in area
- Two-parent household status
- Keeping rural trains running critically important for economic opportunity
Conclusion
- DC-NY $22.86 profit subsidizes rural route losses
- Enables $100s train fare vs $1000s flight fare for rural residents
