AI summary by TwinMind
Why were there three popes at the same time? - Joëlle Rollo-Koster
TED-Ed
6m 13s
Origins of Papal Crisis (1296-1309)
- King Philip IV of France raised taxes on Church in 1296
- Pope Boniface VIII wrote "Unam Sanctam" decree asserting papal supremacy over earthly rulers
- Philip declared Boniface heretic, attempted violent arrest raid
- Boniface survived but died soon after
- Pope Clement V elected 1305 as French diplomat
- Clement moved papacy to Avignon 1309 (French-adjacent city owned by Church vassal)
- Sought to stay close to England-France conflict, escape Roman demands
Avignon Papacy Period (1309-1376)
- Papacy remained in Avignon for 7 consecutive popes
- Over 70-year absence from Rome
- Reigning pope finally returned to Italy 1376
- Pope died several months after return
Roman Election Crisis & Dual Papacy (1376-1409)
- Emergency papal election required in Rome after 70+ year absence
- Romans determined to elect Italian pope, restore Rome as Western Christendom seat
- Local officials pressured cardinals for Italian choice
- Rowdy mobs raided conclave, plundered papal wine cellar
- Cardinals elected Neapolitan Archbishop of Bari as Pope Urban VI
- Urban initially seen as safe choice but proved to be reformer
- Sought to limit cardinals' finances
- Threatened luxurious lifestyles
- Cardinals declared election illegitimate due to Roman mob pressure
- Cardinals denounced Urban as usurper, held new conclave
- Elected Pope Clement VII in competing election
- Clement attempted to excommunicate Urban
- Urban refused recognition, named new cardinals, entrenched in Rome
- Clement and supporters returned to Avignon
- Official schism began with two capitals: Avignon and Rome
- Each line appointed successors as popes died, continuing crisis for decades
Political & Religious Impact (1378-1409)
- Minimal impact on ordinary Catholics - no significant doctrinal splits
- Drama primarily diplomatic realm
- European rulers forced to choose sides between competing papal claims
- Both popes vied for spiritual and political supremacy
- Only pope had authority to call general council for resolution
- Both sides refused to take this step
Three-Pope Crisis (1409-1417)
- 1409: French and Roman cardinals took independent action
- Claimed right to call council since both popes disputed
- Cardinals deposed both pretenders, elected third pope
- Both Avignon and Rome popes refused to recognize council
- Crisis escalated from 2 to 3 competing popes
- Unusual arrangement lasted 5 more years
Resolution at Council of Constance (1417)
- Council of Constance 1417 finally resolved crisis
- Roman line pope and third line pope resigned
- Agreed to unite church under new Pope Martin V
- Avignon pope eventually capitulated
- Schism ended after 39 total years
- Church's official records recognize Roman line as always legitimate
