AI summary by TwinMind

Will Manifest V3 Kill Chrome?

Theo - t3․gg

15m 36s

Chrome Extension Manifest V2 vs V3 Overview

  • Manifest = configuration standard for browser extensions (Chrome + Firefox)
  • V2 too flexible with "absurdly wide permissions" causing security issues
  • V3 goals: patch security vulnerabilities, improve performance, reduce spyware spread
  • Announcement made in 2020, long development timeline

Key Manifest V3 Changes

  • Code Hosting: No remote code hosting allowed - all code must be in extension package
    • Makes dynamic updates harder (requires approval process)
    • Easier auditing for safety
  • Code Obfuscation: Prohibited obfuscation (70% of malicious extensions were obfuscated)
    • Minification still allowed, obfuscation banned
  • Background Processing: Service workers replace background pages
    • Eliminates separate HTML pages running for each extension
    • Reduces resource usage significantly
    • Uses mini JS threads instead of full isolates
  • API Changes: Fundamental restructuring of network analysis APIs
    • Focus on declarative net request API

Declarative Net Request API Impact

  • Old V2 Method: Extensions processed every browser request via JavaScript
    • Performance hit: JS analysis on every single request
    • Security risk: extensions see all browser activity
    • Real-time decision making per request
  • New V3 Method: Declarative filtering via JSON configuration
    • Pre-defined rule sets included in extension
    • No JavaScript execution during filtering
    • Native browser-level blocking
    • Much more performant and safer

uBlock Origin Light Analysis

  • Technical Approach: Entirely declarative, no permanent process needed
  • Rule Limitations:
    • Originally 30K rule limit per extension
    • Increased to 300K rules
    • uBlock Origin Light uses ~17K rules in complete mode
  • Lost Features:
    • No right-click "remove element" functionality
    • No per-site scripting changes
    • No dynamic/URL filtering with conditional states
    • Everything must be pre-declared in rule sets

Chrome vs Firefox Browser Differences

  • Launch Filtering:
    • Firefox waits for uBlock to be ready before sending requests
    • Chrome sends requests before extensions ready (race condition)
    • V3 actually fixes this for Chrome - proper filtering at launch
  • Prefetching: Blocked in Firefox, not in Chrome
  • WASM Support: Chrome restricts WebAssembly due to security concerns
    • Could enable remote code execution
    • Firefox version uses WASM, Chrome version doesn't

Author's Controversial Take on Chrome's Motivations

  • Not Bad Faith: Doesn't believe Chrome targeting ad blockers specifically
  • Ad Blocker Usage: Very low percentage of total web users
    • Especially low on mobile (majority of web traffic)
    • Mobile = primary revenue source
  • Chrome Team Goals: Advance web platform capabilities, not serve more ads
  • Google's Strategy: Focus on web as primary platform vs desktop apps
    • Chrome loses money, goal is web platform advancement
    • Success measured by web usage, not ad percentage
  • Security Focus: Addressing Chrome extension virus/malware reputation
    • Common issue with infected Chromebooks
    • V3 reduces bad user experiences

Browser Support Timeline

  • Chrome: V2 deprecation begins early next year, complete removal June 2025
  • Firefox: No plans to deprecate V2, will continue supporting indefinitely
  • Arc: Will maintain V2 as long as available in Chromium (expected until June 2025)
  • Brave: Offering workaround by hosting deprecated extensions directly

Remaining Challenges with V3

  • YouTube Ad Blocking: Significant problems expected, unclear solutions
  • Anti-Adblock Detection: News sites detecting ad blockers more easily
    • No JavaScript workarounds available
    • Direct URL blocking only
  • Multiple Ad Blockers: Performance warning against using multiple extensions
    • Causes website breaks, YouTube issues
    • Stick to single solution (uBlock Origin recommended)

Installation Notes

  • uBlock Origin Light requires explicit installation (no automatic update)
  • Works as "install and forget" content blocker for most users
  • Gorhill (uBlock author) satisfied with V3 compliance goals achieved despite limitations

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome