AI summary by TwinMind
Will Manifest V3 Kill Chrome?
Theo - t3․gg
15m 36s
Chrome Extension Manifest V2 vs V3 Overview
- Manifest = configuration standard for browser extensions (Chrome + Firefox)
- V2 too flexible with "absurdly wide permissions" causing security issues
- V3 goals: patch security vulnerabilities, improve performance, reduce spyware spread
- Announcement made in 2020, long development timeline
Key Manifest V3 Changes
- Code Hosting: No remote code hosting allowed - all code must be in extension package
- Makes dynamic updates harder (requires approval process)
- Easier auditing for safety
- Code Obfuscation: Prohibited obfuscation (70% of malicious extensions were obfuscated)
- Minification still allowed, obfuscation banned
- Background Processing: Service workers replace background pages
- Eliminates separate HTML pages running for each extension
- Reduces resource usage significantly
- Uses mini JS threads instead of full isolates
- API Changes: Fundamental restructuring of network analysis APIs
- Focus on declarative net request API
Declarative Net Request API Impact
- Old V2 Method: Extensions processed every browser request via JavaScript
- Performance hit: JS analysis on every single request
- Security risk: extensions see all browser activity
- Real-time decision making per request
- New V3 Method: Declarative filtering via JSON configuration
- Pre-defined rule sets included in extension
- No JavaScript execution during filtering
- Native browser-level blocking
- Much more performant and safer
uBlock Origin Light Analysis
- Technical Approach: Entirely declarative, no permanent process needed
- Rule Limitations:
- Originally 30K rule limit per extension
- Increased to 300K rules
- uBlock Origin Light uses ~17K rules in complete mode
- Lost Features:
- No right-click "remove element" functionality
- No per-site scripting changes
- No dynamic/URL filtering with conditional states
- Everything must be pre-declared in rule sets
Chrome vs Firefox Browser Differences
- Launch Filtering:
- Firefox waits for uBlock to be ready before sending requests
- Chrome sends requests before extensions ready (race condition)
- V3 actually fixes this for Chrome - proper filtering at launch
- Prefetching: Blocked in Firefox, not in Chrome
- WASM Support: Chrome restricts WebAssembly due to security concerns
- Could enable remote code execution
- Firefox version uses WASM, Chrome version doesn't
Author's Controversial Take on Chrome's Motivations
- Not Bad Faith: Doesn't believe Chrome targeting ad blockers specifically
- Ad Blocker Usage: Very low percentage of total web users
- Especially low on mobile (majority of web traffic)
- Mobile = primary revenue source
- Chrome Team Goals: Advance web platform capabilities, not serve more ads
- Google's Strategy: Focus on web as primary platform vs desktop apps
- Chrome loses money, goal is web platform advancement
- Success measured by web usage, not ad percentage
- Security Focus: Addressing Chrome extension virus/malware reputation
- Common issue with infected Chromebooks
- V3 reduces bad user experiences
Browser Support Timeline
- Chrome: V2 deprecation begins early next year, complete removal June 2025
- Firefox: No plans to deprecate V2, will continue supporting indefinitely
- Arc: Will maintain V2 as long as available in Chromium (expected until June 2025)
- Brave: Offering workaround by hosting deprecated extensions directly
Remaining Challenges with V3
- YouTube Ad Blocking: Significant problems expected, unclear solutions
- Anti-Adblock Detection: News sites detecting ad blockers more easily
- No JavaScript workarounds available
- Direct URL blocking only
- Multiple Ad Blockers: Performance warning against using multiple extensions
- Causes website breaks, YouTube issues
- Stick to single solution (uBlock Origin recommended)
Installation Notes
- uBlock Origin Light requires explicit installation (no automatic update)
- Works as "install and forget" content blocker for most users
- Gorhill (uBlock author) satisfied with V3 compliance goals achieved despite limitations
