AI summary by TwinMind

WTF Do Think Tanks Actually Do?

How Money Works

12m 52s

Introduction to Think Tanks

  • Think tanks = most powerful organizations most people never heard of
  • Key role influencing local, state, national, global policy
  • Hire smartest people, pay huge salaries to argue viewpoints to powerful people
  • Some big American think tanks have more legislative power than elected officials
  • So integrated into political process that Washington would halt without them
  • Perceived as shadowy organizations vs. democratic cogs

Function and Purpose

  • Politicians create laws in diverse fields impossible to fully understand
  • Example: nitrates in aerial dispersed fertilizers + USDA agricultural risk coverage subsidies
  • Most politicians not experts in fields they legislate
  • Think tanks employ experts (farmers, chemists, scientists) to advise lawmakers
  • Produce studies, surveys, data collection - expensive process
  • Handle funding constraints normal researchers face
  • Provide friendly service for lawmakers to call with questions/talking points

Growth and Scale

  • Over 800 think tanks operating in America (MIT data)
  • Number increased 58% in past 25 years (KAS data)
  • Think tank exists for virtually anything laws can be made for
  • Politicians phone call away from expert help on any issue

Funding Structure

  • Some operate as semi-independent government agencies (US Bureau of Labor Statistics)
  • Most have no official government connection
  • Primary funding from companies in industries they represent
  • Donations treated as 501c nonprofit (like Red Cross)
    • Any amount with complete anonymity
    • Anyone can donate
  • Foreign governments donated minimum $175 million to top 50 Washington think tanks (2014-2018)
    • Real number could be up to $500 million
    • Donation records intentionally difficult to access

Influence Tactics

  • Political lobbying highly competitive
  • Big campaign donations insufficient for favorable laws
  • Need politicians with right talking points
  • Think tanks can:
    • Refuse to publish unfavorable reports
    • Adjust reporting methods until getting desired results
    • No peer review oversight
  • Example: E-scooter companies funding Adam Smith Institute reports on safety/environmental benefits

Historical Manipulation

  • Research used to argue against:
    • Smoking-cancer link
    • Sugar-obesity connection
    • CO2-climate change relationship
    • Military spending concerns
  • Tobacco executive correspondence: "Doubt is our product... best means of competing with body of fact"
  • Biased reporting effective at slowing political change that cuts profits

Current Battle: Ozempic vs. Food Industry

  • Pharmaceutical companies promoting Ozempic for obesity
    • Public health think tanks advocating insurance coverage
    • Reports on weight loss benefits for individuals/healthcare system
  • Fast food/soda/snack companies see threat to biggest customers
    • Think tanks publishing articles on unknown health risks
    • Lifelong medication uncertainty claims

Extreme Influence

  • 2018 Journal of Public Choice report: think tanks with extreme leanings more likely cited in Congressional floor speeches

RAND Corporation Case Study

  • One of largest, best-funded think tanks globally
  • Received nearly $360 million in 2022
  • Donors: US military, Department of Homeland Security, other governments
  • Subsidiaries include Hudson Institute
  • Directly involved in: Space Race, Vietnam War, National Healthcare, nuclear strategy
  • Created "mutually assured destruction" Cold War policy
    • Necessitated huge military buildup
    • Government lobbying itself through think tanks

Employment Structure

  • Technically nonprofits but pay huge salaries
  • Many employees previously worked in public sector
  • Cushy retirement plan for politicians
  • Personal incentive for politicians to work closely with them

Legislative Drafting

  • Key function: draft legislation politicians can pass into law
  • Most politicians lack time/expertise/resources to write effective bills
  • Rely on well-funded organizations for homework

Media Dependence

  • Media relies on think tanks as much as politicians
  • Think tank reports featured heavily in press
  • In-house investigations impossible for most journalists
  • Nobody fact-checking the fact-checkers

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome