AI summary by TwinMind

You Don't Have to Leave Your Neighborhood to Live in a Better One | Majora Carter | TED

TED

17m 10s

Core Concept: Talent Retention for Neighborhoods

  • Successful companies invest in talent retention to prevent competition from hiring employees away
  • Same principle can be applied to build great neighborhoods for people born and raised in them
  • Speaker's hometown: South Bronx, NYC - neighborhood with "talent repulsion strategy"
  • 1980s: walked by crack house to reach Bronx High School of Science
  • Same corner now houses award-winning hip-hop café "Boogie Down Grind"
  • Speaker: real estate developer, strategy consultant, practices restorative community development

Low-Status Communities Definition

  • Not called "poor" or "underprivileged" - status implies something larger/deeper
  • Characteristics: worse schools, public health, air/water quality, parks, food options, career opportunities
  • Infrastructure: government subsidized rental housing, health clinics, homeless shelters, liquor stores, dollar stores
  • Financial services: few banks, many check-cashing stores, pawn shops
  • Geographic distribution: inner cities, reservations, white Rust Belt towns, worldwide
  • Expectation: bright kids measure success by how far they get away

Historical Context: Capitalism's Dual Nature

  • U.S. capitalism supported both slavery and Black Wall Streets
  • Black Wall Streets: communities of formerly enslaved people, one generation out
    • Built great businesses, wealth, communities
    • Most famous: Greenwood, Tulsa, Oklahoma
    • Destroyed by white mobs, burned down, people murdered without consequence
  • America's talent retention strategy since 1619: slavery provided white Americans benefits
  • Black Wall Streets built on sustainable ideals but destroyed because builders weren't white
  • Same system, very different outcomes

Economic Impact of Racial Inequality

  • Citigroup estimate: racial wealth gap cost U.S. $16 trillion over last 20 years
  • Money that could have gone into economy but didn't due to systemic racism
  • Solution: apply same capitalism tools that built white wealth to build wealth in low-status communities
  • Focus on property ownership and real estate development

Current Development Paths in Low-Status Communities

Path 1: Poverty Maintenance

  • Concentration of health clinics, government subsidized rental housing, pharmacies
  • Philanthropic and government dollars pour in
  • Non-profit industrial complex views poverty as authentic cultural attribute
  • Programs designed to manage poverty, not improve communities
  • Money made but not for local people
  • Many well-intentioned programs function as talent extraction
  • Promising talent encouraged to "grow up and be somebody" but not in their own neighborhood

Path 2: Gentrification/Displacement

  • Rising urban populations, politicians/activists resist greater density
  • Rising demand + limited supply = price increases
  • Outsiders build communities for their needs/desires, not existing residents
  • Not always mutually exclusive - existing residents want nice things too, leave when they can
  • Neither strategy helps people in communities live in neighborhoods they deserve

Talent Retention Model for Neighborhoods

  • Treat low-status communities like struggling companies needing turnaround
  • Municipalities give corporate retention deals believing economic activity worth subsidy
  • Apply same approach to low-status communities

Nudges to Encourage Staying

  • Lifestyle infrastructure based on market research
    • Cafes, bars, bookstores, farmers markets
    • Build positive community interactions, make people feel cool
  • Real access to property ownership and business ownership
    • Keeps people vested in neighborhoods
    • Like company stock options - when community does well, residents do well
    • Similar to employees of hot startup

Property Protection Strategies

Legal/Financial Counsel for Property Owners

  • Like public defenders for those who can't afford legal counsel
  • Before real estate transactions in low-status communities, sellers should receive quality legal/financial counsel
  • Ensure awareness of land value and maximization options:
    • Sensible refinancing
    • Building vertical additions for rentals
    • Accessory dwelling units
    • Using value for college tuition, business building

Protected Class Consideration

  • Property owners in low-status communities might be considered protected class by SEC
  • Protect black wealth and other low-status community wealth from continuing liquidation
  • Common for property owners to receive quick cash offers
  • Enticing to people never led to believe there's real value in their community
  • All legal, but real estate companies and private equity effectively increase wealth inequality

Regulatory Proposals

SEC Transparency Requirements

  • Recently proposed rules requiring businesses to report greenhouse gas emissions for investor transparency
  • Should do same for taxpayers regarding real estate/private equity predatory practices
  • These firms privatize profits, socialize costs
  • Business model reducing homeownership opportunities creates more landless renters
  • Exacerbates poverty concentration, increases ill effects:
    • Higher rates of bad policing and incarceration
    • Lower health and educational outcomes
  • Shutting out aspiring homeowners costs everyone

Market Competition Issues

  • Some renters pay more in rent than mortgage payments
  • Most needing mortgages can't compete with speed of predatory speculators' all-cash deals
  • Solution: philanthropic organizations buy properties at market rate from fully-informed sellers
  • Hold properties so community members have time to get financing and buy
  • Provides valuable cushion time, chance to participate in American dream
  • Low-risk place to park capital

Real-World Examples

East Bay Permanent Real Estate Cooperative (West Oakland, California)

  • Third generation West Oakland resident Noni Session leads
  • Recently acquired property collectively for permanent affordable mixed-use development
  • Benefits resident owners
  • Offers lunchtime learning sessions on investment and development
  • Current membership: ~500 community investor resident and staff owners
  • Raised $5 million to date

JumpStart Program (Philadelphia)

  • Started by Ken Weinstein (commercial real estate developer)
  • Provides training, mentoring, loans to aspiring local residential developers
  • Focus on women and people of color
  • Since 2015:
    • Trained 2,500+ people
    • 350+ loans totaling $40+ million
    • 350+ units totally rehabilitated
  • Activities improve value of each other's properties, reduce blight neighborhood by neighborhood
  • Now in 13+ communities nationwide

Kelp Farming Initiative (Alaska)

  • June Lankert, member of IAC tribe
  • Securing livelihoods for aspiring native youth and women
  • Kelp farming in ancestral native waters
  • Kelp uses:
    • Traditional food source
    • Commercial components in bioplastics and pharmaceuticals
    • Additive in cow feed to reduce methane
  • Competing against multinational companies for piece of emerging ocean industry

South Bronx Rail Station Project

  • Historic rail station brought speaker's father (Pullman Porter) to neighborhood in 1940s
  • Father won $15,000 in horse race, carried in satchel across country
  • Purchased home near rail station for family (mortgage while black was harder then)
  • Speaker (father's baby daughter) recently acquired rail station
  • Transforming into multi-use performance venue and event hall
  • For music, weddings, quinceañeras, gaming tournaments
  • Speaker: "manifestation of mommy and daddy's wildest dreams"

Conclusion

  • Talent retention won't solve all problems of poverty maintenance, displacement, gentrification, or capitalism's wrongs
  • But won't solve any of these problems without it
  • Don't need to keep building monuments honoring shameful practices that created inequality
  • Using capitalism tools in more restorative way can help low-status communities
  • Goal: show people don't have to move out of neighborhoods to live in better ones

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome