AI summary by TwinMind
You Don't Have to Leave Your Neighborhood to Live in a Better One | Majora Carter | TED
TED
17m 10s
Core Concept: Talent Retention for Neighborhoods
- Successful companies invest in talent retention to prevent competition from hiring employees away
- Same principle can be applied to build great neighborhoods for people born and raised in them
- Speaker's hometown: South Bronx, NYC - neighborhood with "talent repulsion strategy"
- 1980s: walked by crack house to reach Bronx High School of Science
- Same corner now houses award-winning hip-hop café "Boogie Down Grind"
- Speaker: real estate developer, strategy consultant, practices restorative community development
Low-Status Communities Definition
- Not called "poor" or "underprivileged" - status implies something larger/deeper
- Characteristics: worse schools, public health, air/water quality, parks, food options, career opportunities
- Infrastructure: government subsidized rental housing, health clinics, homeless shelters, liquor stores, dollar stores
- Financial services: few banks, many check-cashing stores, pawn shops
- Geographic distribution: inner cities, reservations, white Rust Belt towns, worldwide
- Expectation: bright kids measure success by how far they get away
Historical Context: Capitalism's Dual Nature
- U.S. capitalism supported both slavery and Black Wall Streets
- Black Wall Streets: communities of formerly enslaved people, one generation out
- Built great businesses, wealth, communities
- Most famous: Greenwood, Tulsa, Oklahoma
- Destroyed by white mobs, burned down, people murdered without consequence
- America's talent retention strategy since 1619: slavery provided white Americans benefits
- Black Wall Streets built on sustainable ideals but destroyed because builders weren't white
- Same system, very different outcomes
Economic Impact of Racial Inequality
- Citigroup estimate: racial wealth gap cost U.S. $16 trillion over last 20 years
- Money that could have gone into economy but didn't due to systemic racism
- Solution: apply same capitalism tools that built white wealth to build wealth in low-status communities
- Focus on property ownership and real estate development
Current Development Paths in Low-Status Communities
Path 1: Poverty Maintenance
- Concentration of health clinics, government subsidized rental housing, pharmacies
- Philanthropic and government dollars pour in
- Non-profit industrial complex views poverty as authentic cultural attribute
- Programs designed to manage poverty, not improve communities
- Money made but not for local people
- Many well-intentioned programs function as talent extraction
- Promising talent encouraged to "grow up and be somebody" but not in their own neighborhood
Path 2: Gentrification/Displacement
- Rising urban populations, politicians/activists resist greater density
- Rising demand + limited supply = price increases
- Outsiders build communities for their needs/desires, not existing residents
- Not always mutually exclusive - existing residents want nice things too, leave when they can
- Neither strategy helps people in communities live in neighborhoods they deserve
Talent Retention Model for Neighborhoods
- Treat low-status communities like struggling companies needing turnaround
- Municipalities give corporate retention deals believing economic activity worth subsidy
- Apply same approach to low-status communities
Nudges to Encourage Staying
- Lifestyle infrastructure based on market research
- Cafes, bars, bookstores, farmers markets
- Build positive community interactions, make people feel cool
- Real access to property ownership and business ownership
- Keeps people vested in neighborhoods
- Like company stock options - when community does well, residents do well
- Similar to employees of hot startup
Property Protection Strategies
Legal/Financial Counsel for Property Owners
- Like public defenders for those who can't afford legal counsel
- Before real estate transactions in low-status communities, sellers should receive quality legal/financial counsel
- Ensure awareness of land value and maximization options:
- Sensible refinancing
- Building vertical additions for rentals
- Accessory dwelling units
- Using value for college tuition, business building
Protected Class Consideration
- Property owners in low-status communities might be considered protected class by SEC
- Protect black wealth and other low-status community wealth from continuing liquidation
- Common for property owners to receive quick cash offers
- Enticing to people never led to believe there's real value in their community
- All legal, but real estate companies and private equity effectively increase wealth inequality
Regulatory Proposals
SEC Transparency Requirements
- Recently proposed rules requiring businesses to report greenhouse gas emissions for investor transparency
- Should do same for taxpayers regarding real estate/private equity predatory practices
- These firms privatize profits, socialize costs
- Business model reducing homeownership opportunities creates more landless renters
- Exacerbates poverty concentration, increases ill effects:
- Higher rates of bad policing and incarceration
- Lower health and educational outcomes
- Shutting out aspiring homeowners costs everyone
Market Competition Issues
- Some renters pay more in rent than mortgage payments
- Most needing mortgages can't compete with speed of predatory speculators' all-cash deals
- Solution: philanthropic organizations buy properties at market rate from fully-informed sellers
- Hold properties so community members have time to get financing and buy
- Provides valuable cushion time, chance to participate in American dream
- Low-risk place to park capital
Real-World Examples
East Bay Permanent Real Estate Cooperative (West Oakland, California)
- Third generation West Oakland resident Noni Session leads
- Recently acquired property collectively for permanent affordable mixed-use development
- Benefits resident owners
- Offers lunchtime learning sessions on investment and development
- Current membership: ~500 community investor resident and staff owners
- Raised $5 million to date
JumpStart Program (Philadelphia)
- Started by Ken Weinstein (commercial real estate developer)
- Provides training, mentoring, loans to aspiring local residential developers
- Focus on women and people of color
- Since 2015:
- Trained 2,500+ people
- 350+ loans totaling $40+ million
- 350+ units totally rehabilitated
- Activities improve value of each other's properties, reduce blight neighborhood by neighborhood
- Now in 13+ communities nationwide
Kelp Farming Initiative (Alaska)
- June Lankert, member of IAC tribe
- Securing livelihoods for aspiring native youth and women
- Kelp farming in ancestral native waters
- Kelp uses:
- Traditional food source
- Commercial components in bioplastics and pharmaceuticals
- Additive in cow feed to reduce methane
- Competing against multinational companies for piece of emerging ocean industry
South Bronx Rail Station Project
- Historic rail station brought speaker's father (Pullman Porter) to neighborhood in 1940s
- Father won $15,000 in horse race, carried in satchel across country
- Purchased home near rail station for family (mortgage while black was harder then)
- Speaker (father's baby daughter) recently acquired rail station
- Transforming into multi-use performance venue and event hall
- For music, weddings, quinceañeras, gaming tournaments
- Speaker: "manifestation of mommy and daddy's wildest dreams"
Conclusion
- Talent retention won't solve all problems of poverty maintenance, displacement, gentrification, or capitalism's wrongs
- But won't solve any of these problems without it
- Don't need to keep building monuments honoring shameful practices that created inequality
- Using capitalism tools in more restorative way can help low-status communities
- Goal: show people don't have to move out of neighborhoods to live in better ones
