Summary by TwinMind · 7m 17s

Summary by TwinMind · 7m 17s

Climate Engineering Is Coming, But Not Like You Think.

Climate Engineering Is Coming, But Not Like You Think.

Sabine Hossenfelder

Sabine Hossenfelder

Geoengineering Overview & Prediction

  • Scientific progress difficult to predict but human behavior predictable
  • Bold prediction: geoengineering coming, but not as commonly discussed
  • Climate engineering = deliberate tempering with Earth's climate for human well-being

Geoengineering Methods & Costs

  • Stratospheric aerosol injections: spraying particles into upper atmosphere to reflect sunlight, cool Earth
  • Marine cloud brightening: spraying sea salt into ocean clouds to make whiter, reflect more sunlight
  • Ocean iron dumping: algae uptake more CO2
  • Arctic interventions: silica microbeads for ice reflectivity, water pumping to thicken ice layers
  • Common characteristics: inexpensive, don't require many actors
  • Stratospheric aerosol injection cost: ~$30 billion/year
    • "Basically nothing" compared to tens of trillions for energy transition

Controversy & Limitations

  • Hugely controversial - don't address root problem (atmospheric CO2 increase)
  • Only remedy temperature increase, not other problems like ocean acidification
  • Likely change global rainfall patterns (unknown consequences)
  • Scientific research repeatedly shut down by environmental activists

Research Shutdowns & Regulations

  • March (last year): Harvard University forced to discontinue stratospheric aerosol injection experiment
  • May: Washington University paused marine cloud brightening project indefinitely
    • Allegedly due to health/environmental concerns
  • Make Sunsets startup: unauthorized stratospheric experiments from Mexico
    • Triggered Mexican government ban on all geoengineering
  • Most countries have no geoengineering laws
  • UN meeting last year: no resolution reached
  • UK government recently funded further studies

Predicted Reality: Local Weather Modification

  • Stratospheric aerosol injections unlikely despite being global solution
  • $30 billion/year still significant cost
  • Normal airplanes don't fly in stratosphere
  • Instead: increasing local weather modification programs
    • Take edge off heat waves, droughts, wildfires
    • Eventually hurricanes
    • "Change lot of weather = change little of climate"

Cloud Seeding Programs

  • Method to make clouds rain when/where desired
  • China: employs 30,000+ people in cloud seeding program
  • India: used to clean polluted air over mega cities
  • Indonesia & Philippines: combat wildfires with cloud seeding

Global Weather Modification Game

  • Consequences usually downwind (normally eastward)
  • UCSD research: marine cloud brightening off US West Coast
    • Reduced high temperature risk in US
    • Decreased rainfall in same area
    • Caused more frequent heat waves in Europe
  • Need research on China's cloud seeding effects on California rainfall

Political & Economic Incentives

  • Not advocating geoengineering as good solution
  • Will happen anyway due to political/economic factors
  • CO2 emission reductions: benefits distributed globally
    • Small countries see little benefit from own actions
    • Classical collective action problem (spectacularly failed)
  • Geoengineering benefits local populations:
    • Prevents heat wave deaths
    • Increases crop yields
    • Gets politicians elected

Research Necessity

  • Bad idea to protest geoengineering research
  • More knowledge = better preparation for consequences
  • Time to prepare for commercialized weather modification
  • Future: "Today's weather brought to you by [corporate sponsor]"